Sunday, December 7, 2025

COMMENTS: China's rise was sabotaged by Imperial Russia and the Soviet Union. Sunday 07-12-2025

 

China’s Rise Was Sabotaged — Sarah Paine Reveals the Shocking Strategy

1.33K subscribers
12K views 2 days ago
Historian Sarah Paine explains how Russia quietly undermined China’s rise — a story of strategy, mistrust, and great-powe …

90 Comments

Eng Lam Yeo
Add a comment...
This video contains original commentary and analysis by Professor Mind. Any short clips included are used only to support educational discussion and fall under Fair Use. All added context and narrative explanation are fully original.
This smells like a CIA op
24
Whatever, Chinese will never forget the eight foreign alliance forces looting the Summer Imperial Palace! Karmic retribution spares no one!!!!!
12
Divide & conquer This is what professor trying to doπŸ˜‚ to plant ill will between the new combined forces.
5
Only the West thinks the Chinese doesn't know what the Soviets and pre-Soviet imperial Russians were doing. Its all still taught in the history books, discussed in the political circles, and even actively debated in the current Chinese forums , they don't need Sarah to tell them they already knew in the rekindling of relations with modern Russia, they have to be guarded but also to be have strategic at the same time. To the Chinese, everyone was trying to exploit it at its expense, so the old Russia is not any different from all the Europeans and militant Japan, killers, robbers, thieves and invaders
3
CIA way of making China fight Russia..
21
thats true history
4
Who has read Chiang Kai Shek's book "Russia in China"(θ‹δΏ„εœ¨δΈ­ε›½). I remember seeing that book in high school, but haven't read it. Too young to be interested in politics then.
1
China & Russia are now protecting Venezuela bcuz both China & Russia had vast investment in Venezuela, they will do everything to protect its citizens & investment in Venezuela! πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ«‘πŸ«‘πŸ‘ŠπŸ‘ŠπŸ‘ŠπŸ‡¨πŸ‡³πŸ‡¨πŸ‡³πŸ‡·πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡·πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡·πŸ‡Ί
5
Why is China bullying Philippines in the West Philippine Sea while ignoring the fact that Russia stole their vast lands including Artic Sea access?
3
Russia will be smart to return the land and ask for access to the port as a deal... this will ensure eternal existence for Russia. Otherwise, I see bad things may happen to Russia eg breaking into several countries ... not directly by China though. China could have asked for the land back for helping Russia during the Ukraine war... China refrain from taking advantage of the situation for variety of reasons... they're gentleman after all. So, Putin should see this and return the land voluntarily... in return for strategic help... I would if i were Putin., mainly because not only Russia do not have the population, other than the port, the rest of the vast land literally useless, and they will have to rely on China for long, long time to come. You hear me, Vlad? Youre a smart man, you know what to do... and India is proven ineffective to counter China, also betrayed you during Ukraine war right from day one, so useless even have to stop buying your oil although this is their biggest foreign income.... massive fortune fell from the sky. Perhaps you should pull india out from BRICS and SCO for being a pain in the ass even to you. Again i would if i were you. India is not going anywhere, they need your weapon and they need you to help feed their billion of starving poors... India only can get worse in the foreseeable future... perhaps you should engineer to break them up, just like what Tsar did to China? This is okay since they betrayed you... give it a thought.
4
16:50 - It was taught in my American school, in the mid 1970s. The Soviet Union stripped all the manufacturing infrastructure.
This is western propaganda shit. They are not anti west but it's the west trying to isolate them!
18
Lose the scratchy old timey lines and dots. They don’t add anything and they interfere with your talk.
7
The US is gasping for air in the Brzezinski predicament. Good luck, professor.
The relationship between Russia and China will be like that between Canada and the USA, there will be economic dependence between the two.
Western propaganda. CIA
2
What do you mean every time… Russia is there? Isn’t Russia always there, every moment?? πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚
1. United KMT & CCP, something with the 1936 Dec Xi'an incident. 2. During 1950-3 Korea War, did both coordinate in rescue DPRK from being steam rolled by US led UN force? 3. Some who VietNam was closer to Russia due to its traditional wary of China.
I agree with you as currently China's friendship with Pakistan caused a shameful defeat to India. Whereas, when Pakistan had treaties with Americans but unfortunately dismembered due to India. Currently Russians are uplifting India again against Pakistan and, yes, against China. Europeans were ruined due to American politics. But unfortunately the world is not learning as WW1 and WW2 German and Turkey weakened. I fully agree with this video. May Almighty Allah help humans to act humane.
1
There are a lot of Chinese bots in the comments here
Western media n anti China trolls in full force. We know them well.. same tactics every time.. Divide n rule.. that's their motto always...
1
Nixon was easily one of the greater presidents of the united states solely for the reason that he capitalised on the sino-soviet split; the west today has made a terrible mistake in allowing china to form an alliance of convenience with modern russia.
This cia aunt is very obsoleted. Looks at the era when Mao got all industrial support from Soviet. That was immense and so in needed for China to rebuild its nation. Yes, rebuild the country from war which the US had encouraged Imperial Japan to start invading China.
1
Classic dividend and conquer
And China will take it back at the worst possible moment for Russia, which is growing closer every day.
6
We saw that, but nothing you could do when you so weak .
On October 16 1964 China entered Nuclear Club and this action changed everything for the country. No more to be a Pawn in geopolitical games of Great Powers. Immediately after Chinese nuclear test event, United States used emergency channels of communications, established between US and USSR after October 1962 Caribbean Crisis, to ask USSR to give permission for bombing of nuclear site in Lopnur, Xinjiang, with conventional US weapons. Result of bombardment would be interpreted as a " natural nuclear disaster " admitted by Chinese themselves. USSR said "No ". That's why, when USSR used the same Line of communications in March 1969 during "Damansky Island Crisis" to get US permission " to nuke China" or at least to bomb Lopnur nuclear site with conventional weapons, US said " No ".
China must get back its land - Siberia & Manchuria region stolen by evil crafty Russia! Russia is no friend 9f China but serving its self- serving interests!
1
If you are using history to sow discord between Russia and China, you forgot that China study and knows the exact history. China is strong enough to stand up to the West but not strong enough to defeat them, so partnering with Russia is the natural thing to do since Russia was also rejected by the West.
1
In the first place you are totally wrong because you said they are anti-West but your prince are not working well because it is the west that is anti-China and Russia. So everything else you said would end up with garbage I suppose
1
This is the story of mankind as told in Adam and Eve. Having eating from the tree of knowledge, feel so self smart and but destroyed happiness. The narrators here are Adam and Eve, feeling themselves smart experts, but causing trouble to the world. That is the danger of twisting knowledge.
I really wonder how Russia and/or China political and military circles would react to this video commentary.
And, to support Russian imperialism against China, USA supports Taiwanese separatist minority and Philippina claims on Islands USA returned to China ( Taiwan)...? So making China feels to need Russia...?
Finance all sides is a script Russia is still executing - in Europe
WW III--->>NUCLEAR RISK --->> REGRET COMES LAST...
Just as pariah rougue imperalist Russia who has illegally stolen territories from Ukraine, China must not forget & must get back at untrustworthy self- serving Russia who has humiliated China by forcefully pressurizing the weak Qing govt to cede vast parts of Manchuria (Outer Mongolia) to Russia through unequal treaties, notably the Aigun treaty (1858) & Convention of Peking (1860) In light of the above, China must not forget the humiliation that China suffered at the hands of Russia & so China must eventually get back China's Siberia & Manchurian lands which were cunningly stolen by Russia! Crafty Russia is now deeply dependent & in need of China & China can take this golden opportunity against Russia which is now at its weakest point in history economically & politically, to seize the opportunity to take back stolen Siberia & Manchuria lands from Russia! Russia is not a friend of China & very wary of China but pretended to be on good terms with China because at this very moment, Russia got no choice but to desperately need China's economic power to survive!
1
Watch Sarah Paine other video's and shorts. She acts like a knowledgeable historian but is helding pretty anti China opinions.
What an evil person!
1
Sam, eat your heart out ! LOL ! The Russians were no different to the Yanks. At least, though, they sacrificed tens of thousands of lives fighting for China's freedom from the Japanese. What did you and your ilks do ? Tried enslaving China with opium but failed ??
1
Sara Paine on China's side? This so called historian is an unhinged propagandist trying to divide Russia and China, and India and China. It's historical account is so anti-China and so pro-US and West that she dishonours the term historian. The opium wars waged by the West forcing opium on China for a hundred years devastated China. Not only the Europeans are into this opium trade. Americans too, and beneficiaries include American universities including Harvard. Just google if you don't believe.
8
Interesting rehash of Sarah Paine's work but just China propagate. China"s Empire of illusion was crafted by the British and Russian politics. Both are dictie ships and need to change for the better. Maybe the US is the greatest villain in this. Now working again with Russia to dismantle China and Europe. Create a new war chest as in the years 30-45 of the last big war. I hope the Europeans won't let this happen.
Dont think that the Chinese does not know. Sarah Pane another CIA.
I think you have Nixon's opening to China the wrong way around. I have always understood it to be a US strategy to surround the USSR. China was not a major player in geopolitics at that time. The idea that China rebuilt and modernized prior to the reform and opening up period, in the 1990s after the USSR had dissolved is just plain silly. They couldn't even defeat Vietnam in the late 1970s. Their military was a joke. Frankly, even today it is a paper dragon. As for the US and USSR spending astronomical sums in their conflict, that is only half true. In the case of the US, even at the height of the Vietnam War, spending on defense never got up to 10%, and that only for a short time. The USSR, on the other hand, spent between 20% and 40% on defense (depending on whose estimate you believe) and that ruined them in the end. Just another interesting note. It is not unlikely that the US will play this scenario in reverse, If the war in Ukraine can be ended through some sort of peace deal. Russia would be let back into the western orbit, at least partially (where they would rather be, for a myriad of reasons) thus surrounding China and stymieing their ambitions.
Overly simple analysis. You make it seem like China is the victim. Never mind that China was also an empire that subjugated all its subjects and continues to do so to this day. Russia was also a victim of the Brits and other Europeans who introduced the virus otherwise known as marxism into their country to weaken it.
What a nonsense
6
TAKE BACK VLADIVOSTOK AND MONGOLIA NOW
Sarah Paine is a CIA agent.
3
No, China didn’t defeat Japan. The US did. When Japan withdrew, the Russian took over and gave left over weapons to the communist Mao
its the West which is anti world and anti humanity.
1
Painful to listen to. I support the breaking up of Russia.
3
China was so brutal to ALL it's neighbors for thousands of years. What goes around comes around.
Russia want China to fight a war which will weaken their military asset and Russia will be laughing at the back. Russia leader can be replace by a election and new policies and rules
China πŸ‡¨πŸ‡³ Russia πŸ‡·πŸ‡Ί gives Friendships, Assistances, Dignity, Progress, and Prosperity. Western democracies gives Troubles, Despairs, Chaos, Envy, Jealousy, and Hatred. πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚
4
Useless propaganda…China & Russia are sworn blood brothers! Both are the co founder & brain of the very famous BRICS , created primarily to counter USA hegemony & nonsense sanctions lift & right! And it’s gettin bigger stronger everyday! πŸ«‘πŸ«‘πŸ«‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‡¨πŸ‡³πŸ‡¨πŸ‡³πŸ«‘πŸ‡·πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡·πŸ‡Ί
5
Posted by at

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)