Thursday, January 16, 2025
Migration of Tik Tok to Xiao Hong Shu with Ben Norton. Little Red Book accidentally COMMENTSexposes the truth about China.: Friday 17-01-2025
RedNote Accidentally Exposes Truth About China: The Tiktok to XiaoHongShu Migration, with Ben Norton
Daniel Dumbrill
168K subscribers
Subscribe
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
K
Share
Download
70,219 views 14 hours ago
Join us as Daniel Dumbrill and Ben Norton dive into the fascinating shift of TikTok users to the Chinese social media platform, XiaoHongShu (Little Red Book/RedNote), amidst the backdrop of the upcoming TikTok ban in the US.
…
1,211 Comments
Add a comment...
@weigangfu8826
13 hours ago
I am a middle aged Chinese,I didn't have rednote on my phone,I thought I'm too old for that,but I downloaded it yesterday,just to give those American refugees a warm welcome
1.1K
Reply
47 replies
@gloucesterjet1
9 hours ago
Google and FB was not ban in China. Google and FB left China because they refused to abide by Chinese laws that regulate them. This is important for the people of the world to know. Many thanks to Daniel and Ben.
423
Reply
3 replies
@HypatiaMuse
11 hours ago
I never even got into TikTok, but I joined Rednote yesterday. I absolutely love the fact the proposed TikTok ban backfired so spectacularly This is a great conversation.
167
Reply
2 replies
@ไธๆญฃๆญข
13 hours ago
This incident is so strange. Suddenly, the Chinese doesn’t need to explain so painstakingly that they are being framed…. the Americans and their western cousins flocked willingly to a Chinese app to find out more about the truth of China. Free Advertising ๐
393
Reply
4 replies
@alextjflorida
14 hours ago
This is a historical event even though I laugh a lot about what happened in Xiaohongshu. For the first time, American people and Chinese people communicate directly and are trying to understand each other.
460
Reply
8 replies
@Waulah67
12 hours ago
68 year old Pakistani woman here, I've already learnt how to say i love you in Mandarin. ๐ from rednote.
587
Reply
14 replies
@Darkmatter321
13 hours ago
I'm already adopted on RedNote and loving the community I've found. China is not what we've been told by our MSM
644
Reply
30 replies
@davidschlessinger9945
12 hours ago
I lived in China in 2016, eastern China, Shanghai and Ningbo. I was blown away by the buildings, infrastructure, the food, the culture, the people. It blew my mind away, the technology, the development, the low cost of rent and food and transportation.
309
Reply
14 replies
@ALIEN_857
14 hours ago
Great news; RedNote is now world's famous app. Banning TT backfired big time.
631
Reply
5 replies
@Fottrel
13 hours ago
i never used tiktok but my mom did and even she's on xiaohongshu now. i've talked to her about china a lot over the years but she's now really interested in the chinese model. many americans have become so totally disillusioned and resentful of their society that even the slightest bit of exposure to an alternative system that demonstrates a far more successful approach to 21st century human life can push them over the edge. as an american though, i personally was concerned that tons of americans moving into a chinese space would be frustrating for chinese folks but it seems to me as though many of the westerners who are visiting are genuinely open-minded, curious, and come in reasonably good faith. the chinese users deserve a ton of credit for facilitating this exchange, they've created a welcoming and decent online space that would likely have been denied to them had this happened the other way around
221
Reply
1 reply
@barbarashirland9078
6 hours ago
I just downloaded RedNote and I felt so welcomed! This goes along with my experience living in Hawaii for 40 years. The folks of Chinese ancestry in Hawaii were always VERY friendly and inclusive. It must be a basic cultural thing. It hadn’t occurred to me that American based digital platforms wanted TikTok banned for economic reasons, but it makes total sense. American government has been yelling ”threat to national security” about TikTok, but I couldn’t for the life of me figure out what that threat could be and I am intelligent and well educated. Now I see. It’s about money. Thank you.
53
Reply
2 replies
@tomtube1012
14 hours ago (edited)
Ben Norton (Geopolitical Economy Report), IMO the best Geoplitical analyst on youtube! Learned so much from his content.
387
Reply
8 replies
@dulmmv
6 hours ago
I was watching this video, and when they started taking about RedNote, I paused it, downloaded the app, spent about an hour there, and now I'm fascinated with China. Even if they ban RedNote, I can't unsee the wonderful things I saw. I'm sure this will be the case with many people
70
Reply
1 reply
@catie5939
9 hours ago (edited)
I went to China as a little American kid and I love it there so much. It's so cool to see the US people building friendship with Chinese folks. ๐๐๐
45
Reply
@firavivi5
11 hours ago
China is not perfect, but China is perfect example of what a people-centered government should be. Providing affordable education, healthcare, ulility, housing, public transportation, etc. Everybody can benefit from the development of the country, not just the super rich. People may argue it’s not an elected government, but people forget about what we need a government for at all, good governance. If you keep electing a government backed by the wealthy, everyday people will never get a better life.
338
Reply
25 replies
@twood2032
14 hours ago
On RedNote, the Chinese and American users are experiencing culture shock from both sides.
294
Reply
7 replies
@gingermintrose
11 hours ago
I'm downloading Xiao Hong Shu in solidarity with the TikTokers, hardworking people, who see through the hypocrisy and insanity of geopolitics games.
122
Reply
2 replies
@TanuKart
14 hours ago (edited)
๐ great talk.
Americans need to listen to these two guys
193
Reply
1 reply
@lynnfaulkner2706
6 hours ago
I am an 84 year old ProPal American and downloaded this yesterday. I cant wait to figure out how it works.
33
Reply
1 reply
@TheOneTheyCallTim
13 hours ago (edited)
It's like a can of biscuits busted open. Everything is exposed, and they can't stuff the dough back in the can. I'm loving the whole thing.
172
Reply
1 reply
@peaceandprosperitytotheworld
12 hours ago
Thank you Daniel, for bringing Ben with you for walk and talk! Wonderful conversation! You two are the best exposing the False narratives of the USA and the west!
127
Reply
1 reply
@averenwhite9707
5 hours ago
"we saw this hilarious grilling in the US Congress- "
As a US citizen it wasn't hilarious, it was so embarrassing. The US government is so out of touch.
29
Reply
@RayMak
13 hours ago
China is beautiful. But US paint a really ugly picture ๐
78
Reply
@5v1i100c
13 hours ago (edited)
The funny irony in that act of defiance is that of all Chinese apps they could choose to spite the gvt, they picked the one that is the best at promoting tourism in China. The quality of content between tiktok/douyin vs xiaohingshu is completely different though, I hope those tiktokers who will stay on to create content, will follow the quality standard we already find on rednote /xiaohongshu. Nonetheless, I love what is happening, as in, American and Chinese netizens directly interacting with each other and seeing the love and friendship displayed so far. It's almost like when the Berlin wall fell and east and west Germans were meeting each other directly for the first time. I hope that this honeymoon period lasts for as long as possible.
146
Reply
3 replies
@dualidea
11 hours ago
Thank you Ben Norton and Daniel Dumbrill for unbrainwashing me about China and communism
62
Reply
@Elizabeth-y9r4m
8 hours ago
My main concern is how to survive all of these financial and political crisis, especially in light of the US political power scuffle. The government has really called things more difficult for its citizens, and we can't sit back and bear all the consequences of the bad governance.
473
Reply
30 replies
@wyliamulayye7534
10 hours ago
Hello, TT refugees, thank you folks very much, indeed, for introducing RedNote to me. Yes, It is so nice to watch Chinese people and Americans interact.
37
Reply
@minimalisticapprentice2288
14 hours ago
So hyped to see two of my favs got together and shared a great conversation with us๐
169
Reply
@DemocracyIsBaal
14 hours ago (edited)
In USA, "freedom of speech" is conditional
123
Reply
5 replies
@PaladinParadise
13 hours ago
It is the trend towards unity in the whole world.
64
Reply
@PhiloSurfer
1 hour ago
I am 68 and downloaded Red Note yesterday. Hilarious to see the cross cultural exchange, the beautify scenes of China - it is very touching.
5
Reply
@katarinadicamella
13 hours ago (edited)
I love how you two having discussion while taking a walk in the street of China.
Just two intelligent people having a talk and concern of current situation between the two nations and pointing out some of the problems and sharing your thoughts with the world!!
That's exactly the sign when you living in a peaceful environment should be!!
93
Reply
1 reply
@JS-ih7lu
14 hours ago (edited)
Good to see two of my favorite geopolitical analysts together
84
Reply
@juliettedemaso7588
10 hours ago
I've signed up to RedNote and it's beautiful. I'm sort of lost still but I'm determined and smiling so much. ❤
39
Reply
@ah5878
10 hours ago
66 year old American man, I use Little Red Book and enjoy it very much. I actually like it better than TikTok less stupid American prank videos and more X like readings. I'm going to Chengdu for vacation tomorrow and use Little Red Book as my travel resource.
23
Reply
1 reply
@kko-punch7059
12 hours ago
I’m so so so glad that this TikTok migration or ban (whatever you want to call it) has blown up so big to this magnitude and developed into such a positive force! The USA government actually has created such a monster so
unexpectedly and unwillingly ๐๐!!
At first I thought of it as such a negative force for not only China but for the relationship between the 2 people of Chinese and Americans! Contrary and shockingly it has brought the 2 people much closer, and created a better understanding of each other! Best of all it opened the eyes of the American people who have never been to this NEW China !!!!
I always have a saying to myself: “The more the USA government oppresses China the stronger China will become “!
I hope Xiaohongshu continues to improve the algorithm and the ease of navigating the app to accommodate more foreign friends to get on board!
May the friendship of the 2 people continue to improve ️️️️
47
Reply
@MightySteve001
12 hours ago (edited)
That was a brilliant walk and talk. It's a credit to both of you to enlighten us. Unfortunately, many of my comments were also censored on YouTube. The graffeti district of Chongqing is amazing.
43
Reply
@hsingchen5141
4 hours ago (edited)
Cannot ever thank you two guys enough for always speaking out in favour of our country against the poisonous lies from Western social media.
9
Reply
@maryviolet7425
12 hours ago
Learned more from this than any US news outlet ๐
43
Reply
@supervince110
14 hours ago
Wow been following Ben for a while! Nice to see you guys get together
86
Reply
@kindface
11 hours ago
The way TikTok refugees are finding out about China through XiaoHongShu ("Little Red Book") reminds me of Night Shamalan's movie, The Village. When a villager or two finally find the circumstance or courage to reach beyond the village wall, the revelation is life-changing and life-affirming.
This TikTok event is surely a Night Shamalan moment. (Or perhaps even he couldn't have thought of such a plot twist as TikTok-Rednote.)
74
Reply
@aye3678
3 hours ago
RedNote is a great app and the Chinese users have been so kind and welcoming of Americans. Beautiful to see.
5
Reply
@ChinaTravelogue
13 hours ago
The significance is no less than the fall of the Berlin Wall.
37
Reply
@mijmijrm
13 hours ago
I'm reminded of spontaneous fraternisation that broke out in the WWI trenches on Christmas one year. The German and English soldiers played football in no mans land. The English officers were upset at this and shot one of the Germans.
I expect US to insert ppl to spoil the atmosphere in Red Note.
64
Reply
1 reply
@lostinveda
12 hours ago
This has to be the biggest own goal in history to ban TikTok ๐
69
Reply
@Richard-s1d5q
12 hours ago
The socioeconomic success China enjoys today is the result of over 3 decades of prudent central planning by dedicated CPC / CCP leadership. Long Live China! ๐จ๐ณ ๐จ๐ณ ๐จ๐ณ ๐จ๐ณ ๐จ๐ณ ๐จ๐ณ ๐จ๐ณ ๐จ๐ณ
27
Reply
@sjelucten7150
12 hours ago
I love TRUTH tellers, God bless all truth tellers on earth.
30
Reply
@doreensoutar5130
9 hours ago
Hi from Scotland! I have been looking into RedNote, and this conversation was really helpful. Thank you ๐๐
18
Reply
@mikechiu9767
11 hours ago
The whole thing is so hilarious, it even restored some of my faith in humanity.
25
Reply
@josephjohn444
13 hours ago (edited)
21:04 CIA did that in 1959 in my state Kerala, India and dismissed first ever democratically elected communist government. Obviously with the help of right wing and catholic church. My father who was a hardcore catholic was part of the protests against the government. Decades later, he regretted about it.
61
Reply
1 reply
@liteupcandle1
14 hours ago
๏ผท๏ผฏ๏ผท๏ผฏ๏ผท๏ผฏ！Two of my most favorite Western China commenters are making a video together!!!! EPIC
83
Reply
@hh8397
11 hours ago
Please continue sharing the truth of China pro & con to the world! As a Hong Kong Chinese, can’t tell you how excited I’m that people among different countries can finally see each other from any other angle or finally ordinary people got to communicate directly sharing daily living information.
15
Reply
@lewislane1143
14 hours ago
Nice to see Ben and Dan together.
48
Reply
2 replies
@ooikk8458
13 hours ago
RED Note suddenly pushed to stardom. Thanks to sleepy Joe
43
Reply
1 reply
@bobbylow175
13 hours ago
Two of the greats in geopolitics together going on a walk and talk? Sign me up!
33
Reply
@nancytai1550
3 hours ago
Awesome with Daniel Dumbrill & Ben Norton! Great discussions!
5
Reply
1 reply
@tschoy9388
11 hours ago
Thanks host, first time to see your post. Subscribed. Hope to see you soon. Great video. Spoke the truth in China. I am a Hong Kong People, a Chinese. Thank you again.
20
Reply
@User-nw37
14 hours ago
Glad to see you guys doing walk and talk together! Really enjoyed it!
35
Reply
@63051
1 hour ago
Kudos guys. You are doing a great job for validating what many in the world today are slowly becoming aware - America's hypocrisy, mischief making and the biggest threat to humanity.
3
Reply
1 reply
@pc0086
9 hours ago
I'm Chinese, 45 years old, moved to America about 20 years ago. I took my husband to visit China the first time in 2008, he got sick, caught some stomach virus, caused project tile vomiting and uncontrollable diarrhea. I took him to the nearby hospital ER, he received care immediately, IV therapy started, and x-Ray, labs, CT as well. He couldn't believe that I only paid about $40 for the ER visit with complete care, because he walked out almost 100% better after 2 hrs of IV therapy. I regretted not insisted to move back to China when we had the oppotunity in 2008. But, I must admit that life in the US is easier for us, a little less job competition compared to China, especially for the kids.
20
Reply
@KaiserHooray
13 hours ago (edited)
Great to see Ben Norton on the channel. Thanks to both for doing this important task of spreading truth.
(Interesting to see some graffiti in China. This is the largest art district I have ever seen.)
30
Reply
@masnur7007
3 hours ago
Never heard of Little Red Book before. Thanks to the USA government, I've downloaded it and am LOVING IT.
5
Reply
3 replies
@kindface
12 hours ago
When I see my A Team together, I don't even care what they talk about.
But as it happens, they're talking about some pretty exciting news on TikTok and XiaoHongShu. Epic.
12
Reply
@jinnimoo
13 hours ago
For yrs, I've been following many foreign bloggers based in China, I feel this is the perfect time for them to all rise and guide these poor confused Americans on xhs ๐
29
Reply
@truthaboveall7988
12 hours ago
This is the best news ๐คฃ๐คฃlittle red book ๐ now Americans will study way more about China like so many of us already have
15
Reply
@wallacekatini3424
13 hours ago
Glad to see Ben Norton & You.๐๐
17
Reply
@sleo3720
13 hours ago
Fantastic video on a new awakening of those courageous TikTok refugees thanks to Ben & Daniel, Truth prevails Truth conquers ๐
16
Reply
@ooikk8458
13 hours ago
Daniel and Ben simply great ❤❤❤
19
Reply
@gmanhan8305
11 hours ago
Lot of Americans were thinking America should save China and now, my God!
10
Reply
@dangodson7252
12 hours ago
What a great conversation! First time seeing your channel, had to subcribe. Ben Norton (Geopolitical Economy Report) has been my guy for 2 years now, his analysis are always on point and well reseached. Thanks both of you for what you're doing, be blessed๐๐ฝ
11
Reply
@vincentlee7937
14 hours ago
I still can't believe Ben Norton is now in China lol
45
Reply
2 replies
@kkng5529
12 hours ago
The American government's fib blew up like a nuclear bomb when a tidal wave of TikTok refugees swarmed RedNote, turning it into the hottest new social media hangout. Talk about a plot twist!.
17
Reply
1 reply
@julianzhu0099
12 hours ago
The best collab I did expect to have ๐
14
Reply
@bigeye4520
8 hours ago
You're exactly right, the food cost is about 1/7 of US, even less for health care. I just visited Hainan Island, there a dragon fruit is 3 RMBs, a full mouth dental X-ray scan and microphotography is 50 RMBs, unbelievable!
5
Reply
@roro-mm7cc
14 hours ago
I live in the uk and it's number one here too! LOL the only effect of the ban seems to have been global promotion of a genuine overtly Chinese app.
30
Reply
@sukbadaimonghol1089
11 hours ago
These two are finally best friends....AWESOME!๐
9
Reply
@janelee3130
10 hours ago
In January 2025, the civilian-to-civilian "China-US Reconciliation" international operation officially began on the Rednote App!
6
Reply
@georwoogle
4 hours ago (edited)
Wow, what a treat! My two favorites are together. ๐ The street you were walking along is interesting, colorful. Now, started reading the comments. ๐
3
Reply
@donacatanguma
12 hours ago
I'm a 73 year old american woman. I downloaded the rednote tik tok, but i dont know how to talk with any chinese individuals on the app ๐ข๐ข
13
Reply
3 replies
@biglance
6 hours ago
You guys are ON IT!!!! With dropping knowledge!!!! Damn my kind of people!!! peace.
3
Reply
@Cttomato
10 hours ago
It’s an excellent location to do the video, I’ve never seen graffiti art in China and this was the first time for me to see one… it was so fun, at some point I was paying more attention to the art than these two distinguished gentlemen. Make no mistake, they totally rock, I’m a fan of both. Daniel did a great service and courage covering the hk protest (I was there, and I thought it was both surreal and painful to see what was happening on the ground and yet reading news reports in mainstream media) , and Ben is amazing when it comes to explaining geopolitics - he was the first one for me to successfully explain and highlight the importance of China’s digital sovereignty
I find it quite funny seeing Ben with a smile, he’s always been with a serious face on and it’s pretty evident he finds the whole xiaohongshu situation hilarious
7
Reply
@theresabarzee1463
13 hours ago
Fantabulous discussion. I was getting a little motion sick walking along w/you both as you are talking ! Good thing no gum chewing too, eh!? Love this work. Thank you both!
10
Reply
@kpw84u2
13 hours ago
Great seeing Ben here and talking about this with you. ✌๐ผ
10
Reply
@china8674
13 hours ago
this us historic moments for two national people... welcome to china๐
15
Reply
@hannibalyin8853
14 hours ago
two of my favorites Ytuber! hope to see you guys on rednote too!๐
23
Reply
1 reply
@dayveda3736
12 hours ago
Fascinating discussion ๐ฏ๐ฃ๐ข๐ค๐ป
11
Reply
@francistango9171
13 hours ago
Anyway good conversation, Daniel and Ben ๐๐
14
Reply
@jeffery-r1l
12 hours ago
Ben and Den are great for China and world❤❤❤❤
7
Reply
@liz-sy2lj
9 hours ago
as they are walking, i'm noticing how clean the city is.
3
Reply
@diosamurcielaga9418
8 hours ago
I am loving the colorful street art on the walls as the walk.
Great conversation, very clear points. A big hug from Mexico!
3
Reply
@clearvision07
8 hours ago (edited)
I ca testify to the fact that you can leave your baggage in a restaurant, airport and rom around without worrying it may get stolen. I even discarded my Calvin Klien jacket on purpose because it was too hot and soon was brought back to me by the airport security.
4
Reply
@sciagurrato1831
7 hours ago
Ben is the best, eloquent and humane. We are so fortunate to have his reports.
2
Reply
@Lenny2Lux
13 hours ago
Thanks for the independent news report from the streets.
14
Reply
@MalFlower
5 hours ago
Great video!! Brian Berletic at the New Atlas covers this story about how important it is for all countries to control their "information space". The globalisation of Chinese social media apps would certainly help break the US's malicious power over nations.
2
Reply
@lifeofmichaely3556
11 hours ago
Great video once again, so informative love the casual walk and chat. It is truly so sad of so much hate, jealousy, misinfo of China and its people from the West, yet the West is completely falling apart. All they are waiting are bad news of China , whats with this sad mentality ? Facts are facts at the end of the day its clear which people are happier and have better access to life as a whole.
11
Reply
@foresttor4733
14 hours ago
It happened in the 13th century BCE the last time in the Red Sea, I'm not going to miss it this time with the Little Red Book.
22
Reply
4 replies
@alexlau777
11 hours ago
Truth will ultimately prevail.
4
Reply
@prajnasamadhi60
11 hours ago
Wonderful colab.
Such vibe and so informative. Thanks guys.
3
Reply
@msotomaior
9 hours ago
Glad to see you both ๐
Continue the amazing job you are doing.
3
Reply
@valuedent6485
1 hour ago
thank you Daniel and Ben!!!! ๐๐๐๐๐๐
Reply
@nickl1177
13 hours ago
Great foresight China for not letting US social platform into the country. People underestimated soft power when it is more insidious.
9
Reply
1 reply
@limhong1095
9 minutes ago
Thank u ๐ Daniel and Ben ๐ช
1
Reply
@jeffery-r1l
12 hours ago
Knowlegable Ben for China and world in Peace.
5
Reply
@itsmeGeorgina
12 hours ago
Yep!! I'm there !! Since 3 days ago, and I'm vastly happy therem talking about Luigi without my comments being censored and deleted ❤
8
Reply
2 replies
@CarpsterKing
13 hours ago
Two brilliant wise men whenever together always think alike..
7
Reply
@qinfugu2816
2 hours ago
this confirms that you guys always tell the truth๐๐๐
1
Reply
@ZenLH
12 hours ago
A lot discussion on TT-Rednote lately but this is more insightful analysis ๐๐๐๐
7
Reply
@Jeda5479
7 hours ago (edited)
I saw in Red Note a Chinese student just post a question about the answers of her English homework randomly in the comment section. The community helped her to choose the right answers. What a global village.
2
Reply
1 reply
@katydidcottage1556
11 hours ago
Have to share this now. Thanks, gentlemen. Excellent work!
4
Reply
@sasuofficial3448
13 hours ago
It's great . China is cool ๐ . The platform is superb .
11
Reply
@munhengtsoi4492
11 hours ago
Talking about media and digital sovereignty, Singapore has shown how to do it. By insisting on the right of reply to their “inaccuracies” and calling their bluff about free press by allowing them to publish but with all advertising removed.
4
Reply
@alifm40DS
13 hours ago
13:05 Thanks Ben, for explaining about Xiaohongsu.
Because, before that, i was wondering why many people think its just another Tiktok and after, i hear Ben explanation. I check the application itself and He's correct XiaoHongSu is more like Instagram than Tiktok.
12
Reply
@samyang5873
12 hours ago
Incredible !! Huge migration from Tic Toc to Red Note !! Another world's biggest migration on the way , Year Of The Snake !!๐ Nice video. Greetings from S'pore ๐บ
11
Reply
@pointyfingers
10 hours ago
This was incredible. Instant follow.
4
Reply
@anqimel
13 minutes ago
Thank you for making the video, I'm a Chinese living in Australia for over 10 years, everytime I go back to China I'm amazed by the technology and infrastructure development years by years, it's very different from 15 years ago, I'm so proud being a Chinese ❤
Reply
@fillyjamalama5201
12 hours ago
Daniel & Ben, it couldn't get any better!:)
3
Reply
@pukahuroad3967
2 hours ago
I am looking forward to more excellent collaborations between Daniel and Ben.
Thank you from En Zed.
Reply
@Tabula_Rasa1
12 hours ago
Interesting seeing Ben in the wild and not confined to that office space. Also, they chose to walk in a graffitti section that is authorized by the govt. Banning Tik Tok led to Sino-US friendship among the youth.... Something that the Chinese president keep talking about when he was in SanFran. The youth are the future.
7
Reply
@boonhongchan1853
11 hours ago
Food prices at 1/7th of that in the US??? Everything else in China is so much more affordable???
Why??? Should Governments of the high cost nations be asking "how can they reduce that wide disparities". If we need to increase our efficiencies and be more competitive, we need to educate ourselves about how to go about it. Let's forget about misinforming our own people. It's costing us lots and not getting us anywhere.
5
Reply
1 reply
@summerlotus3966
12 hours ago
A very meaningful and informative conversation you both had there. I enjoyed listening to it. Thanks..!!
4
Reply
@hocyrusgreat9324
6 hours ago
For those who adapted will have a future. For those who stubborn will become a classic.
2
Reply
@physika
13 hours ago
Thanks for the great video. I managed to listen throughout as well as seeing the environment there.๐
Not a Tiktok or XiaoHongShu user as I get my info about China through Chinese media.
10
Reply
1 reply
@mohmeegaik6686
7 hours ago
Hi Ben Norton & Daniel Dumbrill.
2
Reply
@a_viewerv2069
13 hours ago
Great discussion, well said, thank you ๐
6
Reply
@lorisreflections6532
7 hours ago
We continue to be gaslit by our politicians. Everything you are saying is what I’ve been thinking. Thank you for reminding me I’m not the crazy one.
1
Reply
@welldone4852
13 hours ago
Thank you Daniel. Your work is moving world history. Keep up the good work ๐
5
Reply
@jackielee224
1 hour ago
Thanks Daniel have Ben on!!
Reply
@theansangong2659
12 hours ago
Both of you are fantastic!
4
Reply
@zhinan888
8 hours ago
It is so funny that the tiktok ban has done more to promote Chinese culture than Confucian Institutes ever did. ๐
3
Reply
@bsure4
13 hours ago
We need all the alternate news sites we can get, thanks for the facts!!๐๐
5
Reply
@chrislivesinreality8245
9 hours ago
Great to see you again, Daniel.
Ben, you have become a very reliable truth teller for me to reference and also recommend. Thanks!
1
Reply
@ykwong230
12 hours ago
Great chat from both ❤
5
Reply
@darcyadsit4653
2 hours ago
If the USA decided to go into an actual physical conflict of the large-scale destructive kind of which it tends to do, I will absolutely stand with China, physically. I will go there and assist them in any way I can, to the point of formally enlisting on their side.
1
Reply
1 reply
@crazoy2025
11 hours ago
great video. Daniel has been in China for 16 years.
3
Reply
@Infodawg2012
2 hours ago
Two seriously smart guys in conversation....what more can you ask for.
Reply
@hongqingxiang3374
12 hours ago
Thank you both for your this sharing๐๐๐
3
Reply
@jimmylam9846
8 hours ago
...that is why the country called "The People's Republic of China" .People is always the first priority in the governments' mind.
1
Reply
@bobjack2381
13 hours ago
I love Ben Norton and Daniel I hope you carry on for a long time thank you for telling the true
9
Reply
@ChrisZ901
6 hours ago (edited)
Ben Norton in China?! I didn't know he had been in China for so long already ❤❤๐๐ welcome to China!! You are one of my favorite YouTuber!
1
Reply
@alberthuang4868
12 hours ago
Always great to listen to these two brilliant thinkers. Just enjoyed the discussion so much
3
Reply
@Hoho-ww5yh
2 hours ago
This is such a great one! The interviewee and interviewer are both wonderful ! Love the content and love your conversations ๐
Reply
@tomcarpocalypse5326
10 hours ago
Just downloaded The Little Red Book
6
Reply
@WayneYeung
55 minutes ago
The graffiti in the background of this video is amazing!
1
Reply
@moreless2690
12 hours ago
Traveling to China is only possible for the wealthy. The US government has excelled in maintaining inflation, housing, and rent, resulting in over 76% of people living paycheck to paycheck. In 2024, the United States experienced its highest level of homelessness on record, with more than 770,000 people experiencing homelessness, which was an 18% increase from 2023.
5
Reply
1 reply
@mateopan3349
8 minutes ago
Thank you Daniel and Ben, a very informative and hopeful account.
Reply
@boonhongchan1853
11 hours ago
hey that 'little red book' is ideal for helping us educate our nation to increase efficiencies and become more competitive.
Ya!!! MSM be lots, lots more like that little red book. Go.
5
Reply
@hjw2405
54 minutes ago
Current Tiktok CEO is a Singaporean but Tiktok is never a Singapore company. Just to correct it.
1
Reply
@Neuvari
14 hours ago
heeeey daniel and ben!! im surprised you two geot in touch
9
Reply
@HappyPandaBear73
5 hours ago
Thank you so very much, Daniel & Ben!๐๐๐๐จ๐ณ๐๐ผ๐๐❗️
Reply
@louiserobinson9776
13 hours ago
A giant own goal for the U.S. government!๐๐
8
Reply
@UeharaKeitaroไธๅๆตๅคช้
3 hours ago
The younger generation of Americans have become Class Conscious.
1
Reply
@davidcheung6404
12 hours ago
The west every accusation is a self confession ๐
6
Reply
@braveshine2579
12 hours ago
it is really refreshing to see ben noton living outside.
3
Reply
@iamchou45
9 hours ago
Daniel and Ben! My men!
Greetings from New York.
1
Reply
@ABritishRefugeeinChina
13 hours ago
That graffiti wall is amazing!
9
Reply
2 replies
@crunchywhetstone
14 hours ago
Extremely informative content
9
Reply
@willng247
12 hours ago (edited)
This is the first time I’ve seen graffiti’s on the streets in China.
5
Reply
1 reply
@BlockchaininChina
3 hours ago
China is great place to live. I'm in Chongqing like you guys. Great video ๐๐
1
Reply
@greenbug3335
13 hours ago
Wow two great men, thank you guys.
8
Reply
@ไธๆตท่ชๅนฒไบ-ๅจๅฒ
6 hours ago
I am also a middle age Chinese guy. I did not download rednote on my phone either. I am doing business in Moscow, where red note is huge among Chinese here, now. so, I downloaded it and accidentally rushed into the human wave from the west. I was like... what the hell happened? is it the rednote I heard of?
1
Reply
@kaitongzheng9090
12 hours ago
welcome to chinese internet! love from cn!
4
Reply
@LW78321
3 hours ago
I'm loving the cross cultural exchange I'm seeing on Rednote! I downloaded it two days ago and seeing Chinese and Western users interacting with each other is wonderful to see. The algorithm is great too
Reply
@Blixey-r9z
12 hours ago (edited)
Correction to what Ben said: Tik Tok’s global headquarters are in the US (LA) and Singapore (edited). Its CEO is Singaporean. 9:12
8
Reply
2 replies
@schumannli5825
6 hours ago
Thank you Daniel and Ben for speaking up for China. US hegemony is unacceptable!
Reply
@steveangelovski6013
13 hours ago (edited)
While watching this i got an ad for RedNote. It seems the YouTube algorithm is working fine. However i also get too many Shen Yun dance ads.
3
Reply
@IA100KPDT
6 hours ago
It's a good and bad thing. Good thing is genuine people can know about China and exposed the govt and media lies. Bad thing is a lot of bad actors can also come in to make this space into something undesirable like most western apps. Chinese social media as a whole is still very peaceful and wholesome.
1
Reply
@marlbankian
12 hours ago
Very interesting !
4
Reply
@limhong1095
25 minutes ago
❤ incredible China ๐ช ๐จ๐ณ ๐ ๐ ❤️
2
Reply
@jonihiu3954
12 hours ago
Fan of Ben ❤❤❤
4
Reply
@eman67rp
2 hours ago
This has backfired big time ๐
๐
๐
1
Reply
@seymorefact4333
14 hours ago
FAN of BEN!!
6
Reply
@gabrielhung1647
14 minutes ago
I really love Ben for his analysis..!๐
Reply
@markusting9335
12 hours ago
ๅฐ็บขไนฆๆ่ฟไธญๅฝ็พๅฝๆฐไผ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐
7
Reply
@ElleDursten
10 hours ago
Its so weird to see Ben out and about lol, he has legs!
Love him!
2
Reply
@curthing
14 hours ago
Red Note now the Red Pill ❤๐๐
11
Reply
1 reply
@dinnerwithfranklin
10 hours ago
Excellent show, thank you.
1
Reply
@InewCenter-t6t
13 hours ago
Social media taking its natural to human to human course. No gov or trump needed
3
Reply
@Shylara
2 hours ago
I want a trifold Huawei phone so bad they are amazing. I was so mad when they made the one I had no longer useable in the US.
1
Reply
@markzhang1866
11 hours ago (edited)
Excuse me, may I teach you some simple Chinese here?
ๆ็ฑไฝ （I love you） English pronunciation：Wool、Eye、Knee
่ฐข่ฐข (Thank you.) English pronunciation：shay-shay
็้ผ（slang：It's awesome. ）English pronunciation：New bee
666（slang：You're amazing! That was awesome! ）English pronunciation：leo leo leo
้
ท（slang：Cool）English pronunciation：cool
2
Reply
@uwo7130
11 hours ago
I love this format!
2
Reply
@umeshutan6959
12 hours ago
Great video
3
Reply
@Crusadxr
13 hours ago
Thank you for the work you do. It’s so important
2
Reply
@glenwjohnson809
13 hours ago
Historic to see ur together.
3
Reply
@AdSinistram-b3k
5 hours ago
Hegel’s dialectic was right: the contradiction of the contradiction ๐ง
2
Reply
@zouinaandrea8168
12 hours ago
Very good video
3
Reply
@PaulMitchell-uj1uu
49 minutes ago
It’s like watching the collapse of the Berlin Wall…
1
Reply
@Alonebe
14 hours ago
Welcome Ben !
3
Reply
@janetupdxpdx3641
8 hours ago
It’s so good to see both of you! Keep going, it would be impossible to get the kind of reporting you do elsewhere!
Reply
@chriswatchingponies9877
13 hours ago
Good stuff, great collab.
Follow Geopolitical Economy Report. One of my favorite YT channels.
Exactly what Ben says, It's ''weird'' that i only learned about Chongqing a couple of months ago.
Thank you. Awesome.
5
Reply
1 reply
@djdamashii670
7 hours ago
wait, you're telling me that there's not actually this social credit score system that we've been told exists for years in China?? :O
2
Reply
1 reply
@lowcc7602
14 hours ago
Great sharing
4
Reply
@laceras1611
1 hour ago
I hope to find my favorite pages create pages for me to follow on RedNote too! Hint hints for Daniel and Ben ๐ unless I'm just missing them?
Reply
@francistango9171
14 hours ago
I mean the wall painting๐
4
Reply
@liz-sy2lj
9 hours ago
my hope is that this move to rednote makes the US the laughing stock of the world. let's keep going with this...expand on it, develop it, grow it!!!
2
Reply
@honestymonk
13 hours ago
Why build an international version of xiaohongshu if we know it will ban by U.S gov? Let American people come in our local version app, if U.S gov doesn't like it, just build a GFW.
3
Reply
@chilenobarrucia
11 hours ago
I loved the walk through both outdoors and the informative conversation style. Thank you!
Reply
@jennyohara4011
14 hours ago
Can we get Red Note in Australia?
3
Reply
3 replies
@EchosJourneys
8 hours ago
Great conversation! Thank you, gentlemen.
Reply
@lynnj7693
10 hours ago (edited)
Ben is right. I am a long time RedNote/xiaohongshu user. I don’t use Weibo because I am tired of politics and arguments. RedNote is more peaceful compared to other apps. We share lifestyles, hobbies and things that would make people happy. It was shocking seeing so many TikTok refugees flock to RedNote but I’ve tried my best to make them feel welcomed.
2
Reply
@suckmemore
13 hours ago
Just heard that elon musk mother joined the rednote too. Hilarious!!๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ
6
Reply
@wwbren
14 hours ago
Good to see Ben is in China.
7
Reply
@JoMe2
9 hours ago
Nice to see Daniel and Ben together. Thank you for the video.
Reply
@AnnieT369
12 hours ago
What happened in Guyana also happened in Malaysia.
4
Reply
@hendetta
6 hours ago
Thx for bringing Ben on the show. Go Rednote!
Reply
@plowe6751
13 hours ago
15:22 I'm pretty sure the Americans know the difference between the Chinese people and the Chinese government.
4
Reply
@KQ0909
11 hours ago
9:20 Tom Cotton knows Singapore is not part of China, he came to Singapore as part of a delegation and met with Mr Lee Hsien Loong. If LHL's father Mr LKY was alive, he (LKY) would have scolded Tom Cotton (till Mr. Cotton cannot raise his head) for insinuating Singapore is part of China, Singaporean Chinese serve China by asking Chew Shouzi whether he is in the CPC (not CCP). Alas LHL is not like his father. LKY once said "we are afraid of the US, but NOT THAT afraid" (after Michael Faye was sentenced to caning for vandalism in Singapore). I guess Singapore is now indeed THAT afraid of the US.
2
Reply
@mrwilloughby8684
14 hours ago
OMG. A wild Ben appears!face-blue-smiling
3
Reply
@reneleung8199
12 hours ago
Thanks to the both you. I’ve followed both your channels since covid I find the two of you always back up your statements with facts, this is what real journalism is about.
I know Daniel’s not a journalist but he does a lot research before he makes his points. Also he has been on the ground for over 10 years in China he has lots of life experiences there.
Ben is rather a newbie in China but I’ve been following his content for a few years now his information in world affairs is next to none. I also follow his friends Max Blumenthal and Aaron Mate. If you want real journalism follow them all.
2
Reply
@maggiema2777
14 hours ago (edited)
Wow two of my favourite geophysical analysts on YouTube, it is absolutely amazing on little red book recently, the American people experienced a huge cultural shock after they have seen the real China, we even exchanged our daily expenses and bills ๐ it turns out to be RMB 4000=$3000 lifestyle, China beat US in terms of medical care, public services, infrastructure , safety and education tuition fee etc 。。。。
5
Reply
@SarahScott-b9k
3 hours ago
This is a fabulous Video. Thank you................
Reply
@MrKAmsterdam
14 hours ago
The worst thing about Musk buying tiktok is for Europe: TikTok has double to triple the amount of users compared with Musks current propaganda plattform. Wir his current plattform he reaches about 15% of voters and one can say after years of exposure to this plattform all of his users are far-right-wing. Now imagine he gets Tiktok in his hands, double and triple the amount. Germany repeating 1933 - but now together with UK, France, Spain, Italy... - very dystopian.
3
Reply
@lizerich7044
10 hours ago
Glad to see you twoo together.
1
Reply
@francistango9171
14 hours ago
Hi chatbox a Daniel and Ben, good video. I wonder if you are in China? Or in the western countries because so many more paintings are it seems like near me in Amsterdam ๐๐
3
Reply
5 replies
@tomwang5946
10 hours ago
great work, thanks, two gentlemen
1
Reply
@ttw2688
13 hours ago
Tiktok refugees ๐๐๐๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐
3
Reply
@DaveBrown-123
10 hours ago
A question:
One country allows practically only one party in its political system, and that party's government continuously keeps improving all of its citizens' quality of lives and well being.
Second country has (practically only) two (wow!) parties, either/both of which do not really care about the lives of over 95% of its populations' quality of lives and well being.
Which country is better to live in, in your opinion?
2
Reply
9 replies
@plowe6751
13 hours ago
Great for China too because now American TikTok refugees can share American culture directly with Chinese citizens. The Chinese government will love their citizens being influenced by Western culture -- April Fools Day, Halloween, Christmas, and all kinds of Disney cartoon characters.
3
Reply
1 reply
@J3unG
10 hours ago
I am an American and I appreciate all your work and telling the truth abouth China. I appreciate this so much. I hope to visit China in the coming years and enjoy the freedom of the country. China is the future. Keep up the good work!
Reply
1 reply
@simonyang-pe3ux
12 hours ago
Most foreigner friends may only know our first-tier cities like Beijing, Shanghai and HK special administrative region ,but we also have so many other amazing cities for a instance ,Chengdu ,Xian ,Guangzhou and Shenyang etc. hope you guys can get a glimpse of them as well on Rednote and other Chinese Apps.
anyway, Welcome
2
Reply
1 reply
@qinghongli3969
4 hours ago
In irder to support my American Tiktok refugee, I also downloaded and installed Rednote.
1
Reply
@saoyang3358
41 minutes ago
Need all my kids to download rednote ASAP
1
Reply
@TT-mr1pl
11 hours ago
Ben and Dan ๐ช๐ช๐ช๐ช๐ช๐๐๐๐๐
1
Reply
@ahkoy973
3 hours ago (edited)
A new community of friendship between american and chinese youth has started .... love conquers all ... stop the warmongers ❤❤
Reply
@fredvarao3894
10 hours ago
I learn a lot with Ben Norton and you have one more subscriber!
1
Reply
@ElleDursten
10 hours ago
I am listening while watching the background. I Love street art and graffiti and the neighborhood they are walking through is so colorful!
1
Reply
@janeyuin4594
10 hours ago
Great show, Daniel๐ n Ben๐
Reply
@deadlift
7 hours ago
Leave it to TikTok Refugees to open this door! Watching some of the exchanges is just awesome!!
Reply
@TheMysteryDriver
40 minutes ago
The sky don't lie. Look how grey it is.
Reply
@fzmoifzmoi2575
10 hours ago (edited)
Good to see the both of you together exposing truths to the world!!!
Reply
@YellowboyRickLee
9 hours ago
Wow nice to see Ben doing this type of walk-n-talk commentary in China!!
Reply
@learningwhiledoing1
10 hours ago
what a timely chat! Love it!
Reply
@SicMundus24
5 hours ago
I Downloaded RedNote ❤
2
Reply
@Universeiswithyou729
4 hours ago
Thank you for doing this.
Reply
@leechewlung2250
4 hours ago
The food prices are controlled mainly maybe because of the land reform implemented successfully at painful beginnings -- no other countries had ever done before !
Reply
@hanmi1216
13 hours ago
Lol, I opened this video and voila the first thing to come out is RedNote ads ๐๐๐
2
Reply
@่ตฐๅฃนๅฃน
9 hours ago
ๅๅๅ，ไฝ ไปฌ็้ๅคดๅธฆ็ๆๅๅฐไบๆฏไธ20ๅนด็ๅคงๅญฆ๐ ๅๆถๆๅจๅฐ็บขไนฆ็ฉไบไธคไธช้ๅฎต
1
Reply
@1whoQuestions
9 hours ago
Stop using Facebook and any Meta products!
2
Reply
@politicaltroll8920
10 hours ago
The Tiktok ban is so cringe.
1
Reply
@robincobb8611
8 hours ago
I really enjoyed this episode! I love Ben’s work and now I’ll check your channel out as well! Just downloaded the Red Book app. So much to learn and like about China!
Reply
@Brother1961
8 hours ago
Great video, it's the kind of channel that reveal the truth of what's going around.
Reply
@penhdog2207
9 hours ago (edited)
Just realizing I've been watching Ben Norton for years and I've never seen him walk. He's actually pretty good at it.
But seriously, I really enjoyed this. Its nice to see the real China at street level while at.the same time getting a geopolitical dopamine fix.
Please do more of these! Id watch these every week if not every night.
Reply
@NorCalMoDo
2 hours ago
Ben looks like a big kid with Daniel side by side. Unlike when Ben is hosting his own shows. So funny.
Reply
@biglance
6 hours ago (edited)
I thought you guys are in CQ!!!! LOL! I lived there before, dope man!!!! just subbed! peace.
1
Reply
@squibsp
8 hours ago
A US politician thought Singapore is in China?? ๐ฎ๐
2
Reply
@wuhaoouyang7453
7 hours ago
Good to see two of my favorite commentators having a casual walk
Reply
@albertvelasco61
9 hours ago (edited)
Fainally happend The people has united from all over the world.
1
Reply
@wenkeadam362
3 hours ago
So not all migrations are bad!
Nice to see you two together. Enjoy your lunch!
Reply
1 reply
@SwfitUIHome
10 hours ago
้ๅธธๆฃ็ไธๆฌกๅฏน่ฏ，่งฃๅผไบๆ็ๅพๅค็ๆ！๐
Reply
@oceanblue888
8 hours ago
Another hilarious thing is that Americans found out Chinese people are actually pretty humorous, as opposed to the stereo type of Chinese being very serious and dull.
Reply
@Amidat
2 hours ago
Great talk by two great analysts. Hopefully more westerners will learn the same things.
Reply
@marksoh1447
48 minutes ago
Glad more americans are reaching out to discover the world, outside of foxnews. Having travelled to both china, USA and Europe. China is certainly the better choice in terms of cost n quality
1
Reply
@vincentloo7520
11 hours ago
When the policy is right, you will see progress.
Reply
@stevenmoore6783
10 hours ago
Its nice to see Ben on your channel.
Reply
@KiloBee777
12 hours ago
I'm glad the people of both countries can communicate directly. I hope it lasts but my guess is that a few rotten apples will ruin it for all.
1
Reply
@luisanthonychau
9 hours ago
Unfortunately I don't expect the barrier to be down forever. China and US are both going to stop this exchange.
Reply
@philippehuysmans3159
11 hours ago
Keep doing the good job guys ๐
1
Reply
@CreepyCrawly-xy1iw
25 minutes ago
Tiktok themselves banned Tiktok in Hong Kong years ago. So, Tiktok can't cry baby about being banned in the US.
Reply
@Yoo-l6y
7 hours ago
Tom Cotton declared that he will ban RedNote
Reply
@ardenigleheart9467
10 hours ago
Loved seeing the city! Great video
Reply
@safudinsuhadi8287
2 hours ago
No one talks about the beautiful graffiti. ๐
Graffiti is allowed in China ๐จ๐ณ and that's great.
1
Reply
1 reply
@worldofsimulacra
9 hours ago
I just uploaded a video to Xiaohgongshu showing off some of the graffiti art in my town in the US, and now seeing this level of open graffiti art in China x1000000000 ๐๐๐
Reply
@SuperStella1111
11 hours ago
I love Chinese culture and food. I hope to visit China one day and make friends there.
1
Reply
@peterhe7887
12 hours ago
2 of my favs!
2
Reply
@josephgeorge5741
5 hours ago
I hope you are leveraging the platform yourself, Daniel!
Reply
@rosl.
10 hours ago
Thank you for walking and talking, it kept my retention.
Reply
@tc-red9000
2 hours ago
What US people should demand to disband C I @
Reply
@happyendingtang4025
7 minutes ago
Yes, they do improve, at an eye-opening speed.
Reply
@RandomVideoWatcher7
9 hours ago
How is the LGBT community of China been with accepting of the LGBTQ from the US on this new app?
1
Reply
@riceballlegend7757
4 hours ago
Where is this area?
1
Reply
@kumbo77
6 hours ago
what will happen if some one asks what happened on June 4, 1989 on Tiananmen square, they probably get instant permanent ban on xiao hong shu.
Reply
@henbane2247
9 hours ago
Now that US and Chinese citizens are communicating on xiaohongshu, it would be a shame to divide them again by creating an international version of xiaohongshu
Reply
@8est8its89
7 hours ago
Two legends ๐
1
Reply
@daebak_hana
4 hours ago
Im so glad people are seeing the truth now. I been to china 10 yrs ago and i was beautiful and ppl so friendly and helpful.
Reply
@qinfugu2816
2 hours ago
congratulations！๐๐๐
Reply
@petesig93
11 hours ago
6:52 safe streets.... BUT the share bike thrown up onto the power/security-camera pole! ๐คฃ๐๐คฃ The ultimate IRONY!
Reply
@dcorgard
13 hours ago
Bravo!!! ๐
1
Reply
@canalesjuan356
13 hours ago
Can't believe you two have a cooperation.
2
Reply
2 replies
@renato7103
11 hours ago
I think it's a good way for people to get to know each other's cultures and world. Everything will be fine if they stay away from politics and propaganda.
Reply
@nickavanti
14 hours ago
A$2.00
่ฐข่ฐข！
2
Reply
@-------------------DD
7 hours ago
Ben Norton is awesome
1
Reply
@anayhz4471
8 hours ago
ๅๅฐๅคงๆฆ6ๅนดๅ，ๆไฝๅฝๅ
็ๅญฆ่
่กจ็คบ，ๅฆๆไธญๅฝๅคง้ๆๅ
ๅค็ฝๆ้，ๅ่ไธไบ่ฅฟๆนๅชไฝๅๅฎฃไผ ้จ้จไผๆดๅฎณๆ；ไธญๆไบ่็ฝ็ไฟกๆฏๅ้ ่ฝๅๅ
ถๅฎๆฏๆดไธช่ฅฟๆนๅ ่ตทๆฅ้ฝ่ฆๅผบ，่ไธ่ฟไบไฟกๆฏๆถๅๆนๆน้ข้ข，ไฟกๆฏ้ๅพๅคง่ถณๅคๅฒๅปๆดไธช่ฅฟๆนไธ็
ๅฏไปฅ่ฏด็ฐๅจ่ฟไธชๅฑ้ขๆฏๆ้ข่จ็，ๅนถ้ๅชๆฏไธ็ง่งๅฏ็ฐ่ฑก่ๅทฒ，ๅบ่ฏฅ่ฏดๆฏไธ็งๅฟ
็ถ；ๆฌ่ดจไธ่ฟๆฏ็พๅฝไบบ่ชๅทฑๅ
ๅฎฃ้จ้จ็้ฎ้ขXD็พๅฝไบบๅฏ่ฝไปๆฅๆฒก่งๅพ่ชๅทฑๆ็ไบ่็ฝ่ช็ฑไผๅฒๅปไปไปฌ่ชๅทฑ็ๆ่ฏๅฝขๆ
1
Reply
@zzzzxx2011
5 hours ago
Warm reminder: Foreign friends, don't be too optimistic. Xiaohongshu is one of the most strictly reviewed community platforms in China๐
ๆธฉๆ
ๆ้ไธ，ๅคๅฝๅไบบๅซๅคชไน่ง，ๅฐ็บขไนฆๆฏๅฝๅ
ๅฎกๆ ธๆไธฅ็็คพๅบๅนณๅฐ๐
1
Reply
@danielsanta437
2 hours ago
I love this so much
Reply
@seanz7804
13 hours ago
Thanks
2
Reply
@mhc3408
2 hours ago
I am surprised and delighted to see so much graffiti on almost every wall, stairs and stone in the city. Definitely not the image of an authoritarianism gulag.
Reply
2 replies
@BrianMasterz
4 hours ago
Thanks gentlemen
Reply
@junweihe8229
8 hours ago
Ben!!!! love y'all
Reply
@ZodyZody
9 hours ago
I often love to look at movies that connect both cultures. Look at some of Jackie Chan connections (granted Hong Kong) to American cinema. Entertainment is often where we see connections. Hope we continue to make more.
Reply
@glenwjohnson809
13 hours ago
Wow, 2 of my favorites.
2
Reply
@andrewlau9873
11 hours ago
It appears the two gentlemen were walking in a mid-level (or lower) neighborhood. The street scene is no difference from the West, except the cleanliness of the streets. In light of the city probably has 4 times or more number of people than New York City!
Reply
@RechtmanDon
7 hours ago
Got ya beat, Daniel, moved here in 2007! (Jerry's got us both beat, something like 22 years here.)
Reply
@SinglespeedB
14 hours ago
Wow, they are the two guys I LOVE the MOST in this whole universe, （except my family members of x）!!! ๐๐๐
1
Reply
@TurfSurf
6 hours ago (edited)
Just use VPN to access TikTok, like how people access YouTube in China. India banned TikTok and people just used VPN.
Reply
@vzy3680
1 hour ago (edited)
There are two Red Notebooks in China. If you want to know the truth about the world, you have to find the other one. Good luck!
Reply
1 reply
@evanh9301
10 hours ago
I am a fan of Ben Norton!
1
Reply
@MR.G-y3v
11 hours ago
Speaking of being able to leave your bag on the side of the road without losing it, I haven't seen a post asking the Chinese on Rednote๐คญYou can ask ordinary Chinese people why they don't take it.
Reply
@hanchiman
7 hours ago
I just realized I was no longer Subscribed to Daniel Dumbrill. I was sure I clicked Subscribed 2 years ago and after nearly a year of "Silence". I thought Daniel left Youtube, turns out my youtube automatically cancelled the subskription, because I seriously never unsubbed Daniel.
Reply
@Ms_Kymm
7 hours ago
I can't wait to learn some Chinese words & lingo ☺
Reply
@thlim1460
1 hour ago
Most Americans also are not aware or ignorant of their own govt are using US social media like Facebook, WhatsApp, etc to track their movements and browsing pattern no different from Tik Tok. That’s the algorithm that all social media all over the world uses to service their customers.
Reply
@sunrise-sd4hd
8 hours ago
่ฟไปถไบ่ฎฉๆไปฌไบ่งฃๅฐ，ๅฆๅๆไปฌๆณไบ่งฃไฝ ไปฌไธๆ ท，ไฝ ไปฌไนๆณไบ่งฃๆไปฌ，ๆ็ ด้้ๆ็ป่ฟๆฏ่ฆ้ ไธคๅฝ็ๆฎ้ไบบ。
1
Reply
@MadWisco97
9 hours ago
Thank you.
Reply
@foth9982
2 hours ago
China is very beautiful place❤️๐จ๐ณ
Reply
@marlonlo9661
8 hours ago
Now they are learning that socialism is great. Socialism!!!
Reply
@Liboch
12 hours ago (edited)
I noticed their city is full of graffiti but no garbage at all.
Reply
1 reply
@yudiji1596
13 hours ago
Great to see BEN at his biggest smile as I've never seen~! I was reliefs of concern his health condition since he never grow weight is him
Reply
@ericp1139
9 hours ago
The dynamic duo.
Reply
@dharmawiguna3232
6 hours ago
this migration sparks some critical thinking on US user
like simple:
"what they do with my taxes"
"why my groceries is so expensive"
Reply
@pinnysun8442
18 minutes ago
american regime get exposed instead.
1
Reply
@patrickgz
13 hours ago
probably my first chinese walk about video with over load of graffiti. curious though how much income will be lost by american tik tokers since tiktok is used widely as a brand awareness platform, atleast in asia.
1
Reply
@jaywang8911
11 hours ago
Where do you find such quite place in China?
1
Reply
1 reply
@bettinachan7432
6 hours ago
Hey guys, can you look into this claim? Some tik tok refugees said that Chinese in the US is saying because of the flock of English users, red note is separating users by their IP address and so Chinese ppl in the US can not connect with their friends or family. I don’t think how this can be. Maybe some ppl is spreading fake info.
Reply
@jlee8181
12 hours ago
Xiaohongshu just destroyed Biden's14 billions dollars propaganda without spending a cents ๐๐
1
Reply
@honesty_-no9he
7 hours ago (edited)
There are so many China travel vloggers on Youtube and so many EV reviewers who cover China. Those people have been living in a bubble. The information was there but the people who have joined REDNOTE never bothered to look before. I shared China stuff on Twitter for years until Musk's regime suspended me forever (I covered many subjects) they claimed I was "spamming" I was selling nothing all I did was share my posts mostly with people who knew me.
Reply
@paulwei5828
10 hours ago
like you guys ❤❤❤
1
Reply
@kina-fortidnutidogfremtid4528
9 hours ago
Thanks to Ben and Daniel.
But the background with miles of grafitti was so disturbing to watch. I been to China ten times and I never saw any grafitti....pls. tell us what going on in the area you are walking ?
Reply
@f16poor
6 hours ago
@27:00 The background wall sure can use some pressure washing!
Reply
1 reply
@mabanomet9879
3 hours ago
How tall are you Daniel???
1
Reply
@Silver-o1z
6 hours ago
there are good people and bad people and that is the truth. But as long as you keep your eyes clear and see the truth , you'll avoid going near the bad parts naturally. I don't know why they would think other cultures are bad when nobody is harming anything๐
Reply
@Iquey
3 hours ago
I'm trying to keep an open mind with Xiaohongshu. I don't want to get my hopes up too high. I guess I'm just used to people being toxic in the US that I'm not completely convinced that the niceness of the people on xhs is real, but I'll try to be hopeful.
Reply
2 replies
@Perceptionista
3 hours ago (edited)
I am not into social media apps and I don't live in China or the US. so my thoughts are from an outsider perspective (albeit one that is trying to be well-informed).
I have also followed both Daniel and Ben for a long time. And while I understand their enthusiasm (along with other anti-imperialists in many forums) on cheering this development. I remain very skeptical. How do we know for sure that the ban AND the influx of Tik Tok refugees, is NOT a calculated move by the US Empire particularly by its intelligence to gather information and to get a good picture on things inside China including about public sentiment from Chinese netizens? (for example the news about US users asked Chinese users to show pictures of streets and daily life inside the country) Or worse, to foment false imaging about life in the West among Chinese netizens that could one day become seeds of a colored revolution? To think such a development is not going to be exploited by that intelligence apparatus is dangerously naive.
Maybe others who are well versed with the workings of xhs will know better and whether this can be monitored. But in the matters of geopolitics, we always need to have a base assumption that the Empire is not stupid or short-sighted. The fall of Syria that Ben also mentioned, is a case in point. We cannot wholly assume that this Congressional ban is a backfire or bungled move but there could very well be sophisticated and long term plans by the US. As anti-imperialists we need to be vigilant about that. So I think cautionary pessimism is warranted.
Reply
4 replies
@soopajdelux
9 hours ago
that city looks so awesome!!
Reply
@qjtvaddict
8 hours ago
I support the defender of freedom and democracy #1 PRC Peoples Republic of China ๐๐๐๐๐
๐
๐
1
Reply
@yunzhang9471
5 hours ago
๐๐ so many ๆๆดๅ็บ graffiti in the background I can’t even focus
1
Reply
1 reply
@desert.mantis
5 hours ago
Good walk-n-talk! Now, what did you guys have for lunch?๐ค
Reply
@OPTIONALWATCH
3 hours ago
I downloaded it but I don't know how to assign my cellphone to the app and can't comment. I tried assigning it but it doesn't register and I don't get the code
Reply
1 reply
@Lagoost
7 hours ago
The painting wall is so long ๐ฎ
Reply
@yenphung8809
7 hours ago
My 2 favorite hosts.
Reply
@iAN-in9en
5 hours ago
that's a beautiful street.
Reply
@kammantom
12 hours ago
Give credit to the Chinese Communist Party to raise up live living standards and earning upgrades for the working class and growing middle class.๐๐๐
1
Reply
@userngo09.02bmo
11 hours ago
Just downloaded the App...
1
Reply
@Stta-p5q
9 hours ago
It's surprising that the local government tolerate graffiti in this part of the city. Try that in Singapore and you'll get caned at a minimum.
Reply
@MiB-
13 hours ago
It's 500 mil + 1.6 bil US Government project/program ‼️
Reply
@sitiruhanaruhana3808
13 hours ago
Wow.. ๐๐๐๐๐ค๐ค❤️❤️
2
Reply
@fenxian
10 hours ago
let's see if US allowed use VPN to access TikTok after banning it✌️
Reply
@liz-sy2lj
9 hours ago
i want to live in China! 1/7th the cost for food!!!!!! we are so screwed in the US. how can i move there as a retiree? there's got to be a way.
Reply
@hellojack623
11 hours ago (edited)
What truly shocked me is some Americans found and started to enjoy Xue Xi Qianng Guo ๅญฆไน ๅผบๅฝ, which is commonly known as a government propaganda app, omg๐
Reply
@DJ_Randy_B
13 hours ago
๐ฌ๐พ Hey Ben. Love your work. Can you pronounce Guyana as guy-ana not gee-ana? ๐ฅฐ
1
Reply
@Caroline_Tyler
7 hours ago (edited)
How does red note deal with people asking about what happened in 1989 at Tiananmen Square?
1
Reply
@moter2179
9 hours ago
Housing in china is not dying in rent as well!
Reply
@WonderfulCan
9 hours ago
CA$20.99
Thanks!
Reply
Daniel Dumbrill
·
1 reply
@JohnnyPaulTutaki
8 hours ago
Next to America, China shines bright and bold.
Reply
@BackpackerDuanGuoXia
9 hours ago
I just downloaded Rednote
1
Reply
@iwantmorenews557
11 hours ago
Ben looks so different in the wild ๐
2
Reply
@sayaandyangsaya2756
10 hours ago
Haha, who is not freedom country is getting more obvious now~
1
Reply
@sirens7421
12 hours ago
Loving the amount of content recently. As a young American who doesn't use tiktok but has been using Xiaohongshu and Douyin for a while, the massive american influence is more than a little annoying. I hope that something positive comes of it though.
1
Reply
1 reply
@GwynneM
8 hours ago
I think a lot of us are really enjoying ๅฐ็บขไนฆ because it's not a political app. We want the breathing room from the constant polarization on American social media platforms. And I'm sure many will end up joining the other Chinese social media apps once they get a better grasp of the language.
Reply
@ๅทจ้พ้ฉฌ่ตๅ
11 hours ago
$9.99
Thanks!
Reply
Daniel Dumbrill
·
1 reply
@patbyrneme007
12 hours ago
Can we have a free Chinese version of YouTube without adverts and censorship.
Reply
4 replies
@Klausjp.ontheroadagain
5 hours ago
but most american cannot understand this. I am only lucky I was able to travel all my life.
1
Reply
@candiced2138
6 hours ago
Looking at all of the graffiti they can’t possibly have a social credit system/score
Reply
3 replies
@jsyo9639
6 hours ago
Well, I don’t ve TT, but I m going to download Rednote apps today
Reply
@azmonrougier
11 hours ago
it's not really political... at least not at it's core... it's economic... the rich don't want competition... it's protectionism...
Reply
@cappadoccia
13 hours ago
Question: are those graffiti on the walls of Chongqing? Are they allowed?
1
Reply
1 reply
@kaitlynkitty1917
13 hours ago
I didn't realize just how tiny Ben Norton is.
1
Reply
3 replies
@MrKAmsterdam
14 hours ago
btw.. what is the metro station you started the walk?
Reply
@xueueux
25 minutes ago
I really don't get it, why people in the west suddenly move to rednote? ๐
๐
๐
what's the context and why??
Reply
@yehuo2825
5 hours ago
nice vid!
Reply
@sjelucten7150
12 hours ago
It's God's way of telling His creatures the truth, nothing but the TRUTH.
Reply
@cdramafan
5 hours ago
Of course we have heard of Chongqing — Xiao Zhan is from there!
Reply
@SukhdevSingh-ge5rj
1 hour ago
๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐๐๐ฅ๐ฅ๐ฅ๐ฅ☪️๐๐๐ช๐ช๐ช๐ from Malaysia ๐ฒ๐พ๐ฒ๐พ๐ฒ๐พ๐ฒ๐พ๐ฒ๐พ๐ฒ๐พ๐ฒ๐พ
1
Reply
@andyt3343
2 hours ago
CHYNAAAAAA... is great!
Reply
@ChiliCandyTx
10 hours ago
Wow this sounds so incredible ❤I remember seeing a video of someone walking up to a kiosk & ordering food from a restaurant & a drone was flying in their air to deliver their food ๐ณ. I was so mind blown! I’m in San Antonio, Texas & our city is further behind than other cities in the US so when we see things it’s like Whoooaaahh how convenient to get your food delivered like that!
1
Reply
2 replies
@kwantaichan
3 hours ago
Could u explain the background "graffiti" is kind of an event in the particular area in ChunQing, China. Surely I did not see that all over China. (Not the same thing which appear in the U.S.)
Reply
Daniel Dumbrill
·
2 replies
@partizanSquad
3 hours ago
I thought Ben Norton would be taller than this
Reply
@hongjian3714
6 hours ago
Ben Norton!
Reply
@minanovkiril
12 hours ago
the irony that the app is called ,,red note,, literally mao's communist book ๐
๐
1
Reply
@johnkoester1733
10 hours ago
I think the name is actually 'chun-king"
Reply
@honesty_-no9he
7 hours ago
Please do a video on all that funky graffiti.
1
Reply
@seikatsuseikatsu1175
9 hours ago
Awesome
Reply
@adcaptandumvulgus4252
8 hours ago
I think some of the funniest people are shills. Even if they don't realize it themselves self-awareness isn't a necessity unfortunately
Reply
@pjz2007
13 hours ago
Hey, good to see Ben in plain clothes.
1
Reply
@Artificialinnocence0101
28 minutes ago
Next step: Start reading Karl Marx.
1
Reply
@ไนๆฏ่พพไนๅฐผ-h1d
8 hours ago
่ฏด่ตทๆฅไฝ ไปฌๅฏ่ฝไธไฟก，ๆๅไธญๆถไธ็ดๆฏไธไธชๅพ่ฎจๅๅฝๅ
็ไบบ，็ดๅฐๆๅญฆไผไบ็จVPN็้ฃๅคฉ，็ถๅๆฒก่ฟๅคไน
ๅฐฑไปๆไบ่ฎจๅ่ชๅทฑๅฝๅฎถ็ไธญ็ซๆดพๅๆไบ่ชๅทฑๅฝๅฎถ็้ๆ็ฒ。
Reply
@yqshen5439
8 hours ago
Can you criticize the CCP on XiaoHongShu ?
1
Reply
@xz1891
7 hours ago
่ฟๆฏ้ๅบๅช้
1
Reply
@freemindcanada9319
9 hours ago
Elon is about to get fleeced for a lemon
Reply
@koneos6580
6 hours ago
That's cool. Ben in China.
Reply
@santsuma
18 minutes ago
Thank you, Daniel and Ben! Great5 converrsation...
Carl Zha posted a video showing a compilation of Tik Tok refugees videos on Red Note, quite funny:
https://youtu.be/sSkAbDbvVOY
Our adorable Jingjing was on George Galloway's show yesterday talking about it as well:
https://youtu.be/6TRr1U7kKPU
Reply
@shortainonsense
8 hours ago
Isn’t the median monthly salary in china around 1100 USD and the monthly median in the US is around 4000 USD? Food will obviously be cheaper in china if these numbers are somewhat correct.
Reply
@bao-loan_ly
9 hours ago
Same in Korea,
Reply
@joeymelbourne
8 hours ago
I'm not refugee, I downloaded Red Note this week just to see how interesting average Americans open their eyes to real China and Chinese life lol
Reply
@richardmakiya7188
8 hours ago
La libertad en las redes FAVORECE la democracia popular, que es muy direrente a la democracia de los dueรฑos del capital o sea, la democracia de las oligarquias financieras.
Reply
@NL22356
7 hours ago (edited)
ๆดไบบๅจไธญๅฝ่ฟๆฏไบซๅไธๅฎ็จๅบฆ็็นๆ็，ไปๅจไธญๅฝ็16ๅนดๆฏๅฏไปฅ่ฟ็ๅพ็ฝ。ๆไธๆณๅ้ฎ็ไพ ，ๆๅชๆฏๆณ้่ฟฐ่ฟไธช็ฐ่ฑก
Reply
@minanovkiril
12 hours ago
finally world progress
1
Reply
@phongy45
13 hours ago
tim cooks, didn't even know ... Singapore cannot hold 2 passports ... lol
1
Reply
@DaveBrown-123
10 hours ago
The United States "democracy" allows the voters to choose between (usually) two candidates from each of the Republican and Democratic parties, that the rich / wealthy and big corporations installed as candidates, using their huge donations.
So, this is clearly not the kind of democracy that a democratic country should have.
As long as so many Americans continue to vote for the two mainstream political parties (Republican and Democratic), both which are aligned with the extreme implementation of Capitalism in the United States, the country will continue to endure financial hardship caused by inflation and other adverse outcomes of Capitalism, such as health system run by insurance companies, rising fuel and grocery prices and a huge inequality. The U.S. government (and many of its people) thinks it still manages / controls the world. It no longer does.
It's time for implementing Socialism in North America, similar to the one with Chinese characteristics that's implemented in China, or at least the Social Welfare Model of some European countries, by all conscientious people starting to vote for the Socialist Party of the United States.
Reply
@truthtellerfreethinker7311
9 hours ago
Might China could MIGHT.
Reply
@physiqueDrummond
8 hours ago (edited)
Just as they're talking about safety in the streets @4:55 some bums in the background see them and seemed interested... ๐
2
Reply
@handwerp
13 hours ago
๐๐๐❤
1
Reply
@sueloh5035
10 hours ago
Just show the neo cons control beginning to unravel
Reply
@ronniechew6566
13 hours ago
๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃHilarious backfire!
Reply
@cbsing2805
9 hours ago
Old man in Washington will mad.
Maybe XiaoHongShu can give Biden some retirement fund or at least give Hunter , LOL.
Reply
@antwango
13 hours ago
how has it taken ben so long to move to china! ben is made for china, anyone whos been in china will see governance economy in real time....... a real life project you can see benefit the people in a short span of time.... its mind blowing for native chinesr people to see and witness their surroundings and infrastructure cange and progress every 5 yrs..... most of us in the west slave away ata project that never materialises that probably takes 10 yrs to materialise... anyone in architecture and construction or engineering for example...even a block of flats can be wrapped up in beuracracy.... UKs HS2 for example 50 yrs!!! China built a Shenzhen from scratch in that time with time to addthe worlds biggest HSR system!!
Reply
@bettinachan7432
9 hours ago
Are you in an art district? That can’t be graffiti on the walls.
Reply
@opheliaelesse
7 hours ago
RedNote ❤
Reply
@goose5996
6 hours ago
It seems like you guys are just walking down a regular street, it looks so clean! No garbage everywhere, kids playing on the street, road construction is well walled off with clear signage… this is supposed to be a dystopia?
Reply
@bryanlee3337
10 hours ago
time to awake...
Reply
@mururoa7024
7 hours ago
Okay, time to ban XiaoHongShu too then. What's the big deal?
Reply
@Norbu421
10 hours ago
Comparing cost of food without relating to income is silly and dishonest.
Reply
@charlotteruse8718
8 hours ago
Dumbrill must be spending hours at the gym he's starting to look like the hulk.๐
Reply
@shadowbird2611
9 hours ago
ไธญๅฝ็่จ่ฎบๅฎกๆฅๆฏ็ๅฎๅญๅจ็，ๅชๆฏๅฎกๆฅ็ๅ
ๅฎนไธ็พๅฝไธๅ。
Reply
1 reply
@phongy45
13 hours ago
yes, FB very high handed !!!
Reply
@kevinguo7097
9 hours ago
I just installed ๅฐ็บขไนฆ today ！1ๆ16ๅท 2025。
Reply
@tolmol
7 hours ago
Que buenas chamarras. Si tuviera una vida tendrรญa chamarras asรญ. You should use chinese flag parche in your chamarras.
Reply
@ahkoy973
3 hours ago
The great awakening has begun ๐
Reply
1 reply
@tijnjansen7609
11 hours ago
What is tik tok in Chinese?
Reply
2 replies
@gfmoore
13 hours ago
Very interesting. What is with all the graffiti?!!! ๐ค
1
Reply
2 replies
@AATV-GJ
9 hours ago
ไธญๅฝๆฏ่ตทไธๅๅนดๅๆฅๆฏๅฅฝไบๅพๅค，้ฅฟไธๆญป，ไฝๆฏไนๅฏไธ่ตทๆฅ，ๅบๅฑ่็พๅงๅ้ฃไบๆ้ฑไบบๅทฎ่ทๅพๅคง，ไธญๅฝ็่ดซๅฏๅทฎ่ทๅพๅคง，่ดชๅฎๆฑกๅๅพๅค，่ฟๆฏไธไธชไบบๆฒป็็ๅฝๅฎถ，ไธๆฏๆณๆฒป็็ๅฝๅฎถ。
Reply
1 reply
@JO-et2ir
2 hours ago
Was that graffiti on some store fronts 4:16 ?
Reply
2 replies
@georgexu2502
6 hours ago
Why are there so many graffiti on the wall where you pass by?
Reply
1 reply
@Leaxiaoai
1 hour ago
ๅๅๅ，tt ban็ซ็ถๆญชๆๆญฃ็ๆๅฐฑไบๅฐ็บขไนฆ๐
Reply
@taiwanstillisntacountry
14 hours ago
Sit down, drink a cup of Chinese tea, eat some buns.
Relax
Reply
@greg6509
8 hours ago (edited)
Okay, I joined the app. But 1:25 in you just told a lie. Tell Xu Xiaodong who beat numerous kung fu masters with MMA that there is no social credit score. He wasn't able to fly even domestically and had so many rights taken away from him and Cancelled for shaming traditional chinese martial arts. I love the app, but it doesn't do anybody any good for you to propagate lies like there's no social credit scores in China. That's a blatant lie and with the CBDC or Central Bank Digital Currency, they could turn off anybody's money at any time if they choose. All of that being said, i think i may prefer to live in china than the USA oligarchy and MIC.
1
Reply
4 replies
@MevLanna
8 hours ago
Is the Uyghur things lies? Can u talk about this?
1
Reply
3 replies
@dannytadashi4235
7 hours ago
HAHAHAHAHA LOL ๐ YOU funny . I would rather say - WO EYE KNEE ENGLISH Pronunciation more accurate . Love my awesome and beautiful China always ๐๐๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ Love Vietnam ๐๐๐ป๐ณ๐ป๐ณ๐ป๐ณ love Russia ๐๐๐ท๐บ๐ท๐บ๐ท๐บ love Thailand ๐๐๐น๐ญ๐น๐ญ๐น๐ญ love Laos ๐๐๐ฑ๐ฆ๐ฑ๐ฆ๐ฑ๐ฆ love Cambodia ๐๐๐ฐ๐ญ๐ฐ๐ญ๐ฐ๐ญ love Myanmar ๐๐๐ฒ๐ฒ๐ฒ๐ฒ๐ฒ๐ฒ love Singapore๐๐๐ฎ๐ฉ๐ฎ๐ฉ๐ฎ๐ฉ love Malaysia๐๐๐ฒ๐พ๐ฒ๐พ๐ฒ๐พ and love Indonesia ๐๐๐ฎ๐ฉ๐ฎ๐ฉ๐ฎ๐ฉ‼️
Reply
@SkarGig
9 hours ago
wheres that one American youtuber that is always yelling about how evil china is? lol
Reply
@adcaptandumvulgus4252
8 hours ago
The guy on the left looks like that financial bro that was always talking about gold and other finance uploads that had to become independent and wealthy I forget what his name is though they look strikingly similar a doppelganger if you will
Reply
@JeanKarov
10 hours ago
The Exodus ;)
Reply
@mickyjagah
11 hours ago
"Little red book"
Reply
@HillbillyHippyOG
7 hours ago
❤ ✌๐ผ
Reply
@zhugeliang3905
13 hours ago
Will Xiao Hung Shu ( Little Red Book) know how to capitalise this opportunity?
1
Reply
@minervasheryl4748
9 hours ago
Minus 100 social credit score for not paying your cat tax.
Reply
@qake2021
12 hours ago
๐๐๐๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐๐๐
Reply
1 reply
@opheliaelesse
7 hours ago
I have Android. In German. Can I use it, too?
Xie xie ๐๐ผ
Reply
@happy-go-lucky6794
14 hours ago (edited)
So much graffiti on the buildings???? Almost everywhere in the background? I would expect it's not allowed.
2
Reply
3 replies
@Brent-ob8km
8 hours ago
this is perfect timing for me cuz ive been learning chinese for 1 year now lol
Reply
@JKShorts888
11 hours ago
๐✌️❤️๐
Reply
@turanamo
8 hours ago
How does Ben find time to juggle studies and such commentary? No wonder he is skinny as as stick!๐
Reply
@pamwang4814
5 hours ago
How come people from China pop up here? You burned down the firewall?๐ฎShould’t you guys comply with your government’s regulations yourself?
Reply
1 reply
@gaelsmith7044
6 hours ago
You guys seem to be Chinese paid agents tbh
1
Reply
1 reply
@meis
10 hours ago
16:20 Russia's VK
Reply
@thejinn99
11 hours ago
For real ya'll the comments cannot handle any iota of nuance.
Either something is 100% perfect or it's 100% awful, there's no in between.
In my opinion if you want to live in reality you have to acknowledge the good and criticize the bad. There are a lot of great things about China but there's a lot of horrible things about China. Same for America but this is not an argument for both sides are the same. They're not.
1
Reply
@sctan8649
13 hours ago
Why so much graffiti around this place?
Reply
1 reply
@็ฟผๅฟ
14 hours ago
that was funnyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
1
Reply
@leenz-v6l
12 hours ago
ๅฐ็บขไนฆ่ฟๆฅ็，ๅๅ，ๆฌข่ฟๅไฝ。ๆๆฅ่ฟ้็็。
Reply
@TheMysteryDriver
43 minutes ago
It's weird watching two China shills
Reply
@YaoEspirito
13 hours ago
The graffiti is too much!
Reply
@DrMwenya
8 hours ago
Wait till the tik tok underbelly arroves๐. Theres some madness on tik tok red note is in for a shock
Reply
@JohnnyTipps
13 hours ago
Hmm...Ben's comment about previous violent crime I don't agree with. I've been in China for over 30 years I've never experienced an era with violent crime in China.
Reply
4 replies
@razielgrave224
12 hours ago
ๅท็พ？
Reply
@fbafoundationalbuck-broken6011
4 hours ago
20:00
Reply
@KupiProdaj-b9b
8 hours ago
If any sane person think that current or future U$ gov. -> mr. Biden or mr tariff... cares for citizens, think again.
Reply
@phongy45
13 hours ago
all cia ... cat in asset ...
Reply
@fannyalbi9040
14 hours ago
Oh Ben so small ๐๐๐
2
Reply
2 replies
@francistango9171
12 hours ago
A question for Ben, can you speak mandarin? I just checked rednote On your YT channel you speak mandarin ๐ฎ๐ ๐
1
Reply
@alexdavis-mann8513
13 hours ago
Im wondering about all the Graffiti though! its like everywhere lol whats it say?
Reply
1 reply
@mbnhiphopmusik6429
13 hours ago
Two minutes for something easily identified as not true to be said? TWO MINUTES? Is the entirety of searches ran by "American Propaganda", including German publications? There IS a social credit. The difference is in how invasively it is portrayed.
Reply
@Nausicaa521
10 hours ago
This app is named after the iconic little red book that was the bible for communism thought. Every Chinese had to carry it and study it under Chairman Mao. The name is not subtle at all. Look into the history.
Reply
2 replies
@่ๅญๆ็ๅฐฑๆฏ็ฒพ้
13 hours ago
It's a bit like the "shock" experienced in the Korean war battle field...
US soldiers : yeah we've seen these bunch of Chinese men from Chang Kai Shek regime
Chinese voluntee army : yeah we've seen these bunch of rifles and gears made in US
.....
Wait.... That's not what I thought!!
Reply
@youtubetebie7799
13 hours ago
๐๐๐ Watch first Comment later
Reply
@SWilford
12 hours ago
First time I see graffiti on Chinese city walls.
Reply
1 reply
@Albert_Einstein_not
11 hours ago
9:47 love the graffiti… how is this possible in China? I thought it’s not tolerated in China
Reply
3 replies
@ububox2087
13 hours ago
So can I still post anti-CCP content on RedNote?
Reply
@GilbertEmoff
9 hours ago
New to the show great stuff is tik tok under threat because of its full support of china in regards to tiawan
Reply
@thejinn99
12 hours ago
Hold up there is definitely a social credit system in China. It may not be equally applied because for example my in-laws were from Fuzhou, one of those what they call second tier cities, does not seem to have this.
There is a martial artist Chinese influencer who I follow has definitely hit the social credit system though.
So basically that guy is someone who does MMA and he goes and he goes around and challenges the old school traditional Chinese martial arts, The so-called combat Masters that do Tai chi and so on.
Well he attracted the attention of some officials who didn't like his rhetoric and his attack on what was perceived as traditional Chinese things and so he was prevented from using or writing airplanes or the high speed rail.
I remember he complained that he had to take one of the slowest forms of transportation and stand for like 12 hours a day just to get to where he needed to go.
And while I do think it's awesome that there is this cultural exchange and that ordinary Chinese and ordinary Americans are seeing that we are actually really the same (because remember y'all what we need to realize is that it's the rich against the poor).
But this doesn't deny that they are real problems with what the Chinese government does. For example their stance towards Taiwan or the Uighurs, or the Tibetans, we must not ignore the real issues with the Chinese Communist party.
Reply
8 replies
@lagrangewei
13 hours ago
LMAO
Reply
@OdileAstrid
13 hours ago
I'm surprised to see tags on walls, where are you in china?
Reply
@truthtellerfreethinker7311
9 hours ago (edited)
The graffiti in China like USA .๐ฒ
Reply
@Blixey-r9z
12 hours ago
What’s with all the street graffiti in Chomgqing?
Reply
@OsamaBinFraggin
11 hours ago
Make a RedNote(?) about Tiananmen Square.
Reply
2 replies
@albertoserrano67
9 hours ago
Seeing animal farm in real life is scary
4 legs good 2 legs bad
4 legs good 2 legs bad
4 legs good 2 legs better
4 legs good 2 legs better
Reply
@anyoldthing
3 hours ago
this sounds like a ccp propaganda channel its so pro china
Reply
2 replies
@catrojana3694
13 hours ago
Hahaha ๐คฃ China ain't no Potemkin village.
Reply
@tryfon_94
1 hour ago
I don't didsagree with your critiism of the US, but let's be honest here, the Chinese government is much worse. You can't even joke about Winnie the Pooh or even utter the words 'screw the government'. The same primitive rules we used to have in fascist dictatorships. Yes, we do have immense problems with political freedom in the west and capitalism as an economic system is worse than Chinese socialism, but in terms of individual freedom of speech\expression\movement, compared to China we are like 200 years ahead, even after the TikTok ban. Something as simple as 'Xi Jing PIng is an idiot' is a crime that will put you in prison, writing a song with themes the government doesn't like will get you banned or jailed... If you were Chinese and lived there making the kind of videos you make talking about 'the crimes of the Chinese government' in the same way you do now about the west, you would end up in jail or dead. I'm not anti-China in any way, I just think it's hypocritical to hate on the west specifically for taking away 5% of your freedoms when China is a full-on dictatorship.
Reply
1 reply
@_sojourner_
8 hours ago
There's no way these arent all bots... if you really think china is great I've got a bridge to sell you XD
Reply
@damingchen7497
13 hours ago
All countries / governments censored contents, I think it’s more Americans who believed they are “free”. This video has misleading about many things - Its considered cheap for westerners because of the cost of living. How you try to comment something on Chinese government on Chinese social media. You make a report of the success in China which js good progress, but you forgot to mention it’s because of the open market. Have you asked the local Chinese people about their life and cost living ? Current situations in small cities ? Companies withheld salary from employees?
1
Reply
@kittyworkshop6078
11 hours ago
What's up with all that graffiti?!
Reply
1 reply
@weizhang2834
7 hours ago
ๅณไฝฟๅจๅปบ็ญๅทฅๅฐๅบๅ，้่ฟ็ๆฑฝ่ฝฆๅๅญๅฃฐๅ ไนไธๅ้ไธๆฌก，ไธญๅฝ่ฆๆณ่ขซไบบ่ฎคไธบๅ่พพๅฝๅฎถ，ๅ
ไปๅ
ฌๅ
ฑๅบๅๅธ็，ๅ็ฐ，ๅ
ถไปๅ
ฌๅ
ฑ้ๅพทๅผๅง。ๅณไฝฟๅ้ๅก，่ซๆฏ็ง่ฟ็ง่ทไธญๅฝไบบๅgdpๆฅ่ฟ็ๅๅธ，้ฝๅพๅฐๅฌๅฐๅๅญๅฃฐ
Reply
1 reply
@89itis
12 hours ago
Hard hitting propaganda here, China must be desperate. ๐๐๐
Reply
@hpillsbury06
10 hours ago
Where in China is this video? It is such a dump...
Reply
@Pamela-zv1ln
9 hours ago
Love USA, if was in China I'll love China. So with that said, I know you speak down on USA. But dare you say bad stuff about CCP. Report stuff. Your lying about the freedom there, every country has a good and bad. So be fair when post stuff.
Wednesday, January 15, 2025
Tuesday, January 14, 2025
COMMENTS:Zheng He's Voyages: The Stone Tablet
The stone tablet recovered reveals the true purpose of Zheng He's voyages to the Western Oceans?
CHINA & WORLD HISTORY
9.52K subscribers
Subscribe
435
Share
Download
15,291 views Jan 8, 2025 #china
The stone tablet recovered reveals the true purpose of Zheng He's voyages to the Western Oceans?
Empress Wu Zetian: How Terrifying "Bone Drunken Punishment" She Invented to Deal with Her Rivals?
• Empress Wu Zetian: How Terrifying "B...
The Little-Known Female Eunuchs of Ancient China: The Pain of Castration and Their Tragic Fate
• The Little-Known Female Eunuchs of An...
The Fall of a Queen: The Final Moments of Wu Zetian
• The Fall of a Queen: The Final Moment...
Why did ancient China use paper to cover windows? Does it provide protection against water and wind?
• Why did ancient China use paper to co...
Why Do Birds Dare Not 'Poop' in the Forbidden City? Unveiling the Scientific Truth Behind It
• Why Do Birds Dare Not 'Poop' in the F...
Forbidden City Had No Toilets—How Ancients Solve the Bathroom Problem for Thousands of People?
• Forbidden City Had No Toilets—How Anc...
The Secret Behind Why No One Dared to Forge an Imperial Edict in Ancient Times
• The Secret Behind Why No One Dared to...
Luxury at the Fingertips， Why Did Ancient Concubines Prefer Long Nail Covers?
• Luxury at the Fingertips， Why Did Anc...
The old eunuch who threw Concubine Zhen into the well spoke his true feelings in his later years
• The old eunuch who threw Concubine Z...
Royal Heritage: Unveiling How Emperor Jiaqing Handled the Nine Concubines of Emperor Qianlong
• Royal Heritage: Unveiling How Emperor...
Is it True that No Grass Grows on Empress Dowager Cixi's Tomb?
• Is it True that No Grass Grows on Emp...
#china HISTORY #CHINA CULTURY
Transcript
Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
CHINA & WORLD HISTORY
9.52K subscribers
Videos
About
69 Comments
Eng Lam Yeo
Add a comment...
@andywong7372
5 days ago
Very informative espresso with English subtitles.
Keep up the good work.
Congratulations to the team.๐
3
Reply
@outsidewell6932
4 days ago
Emperor Jian Wen escaped to the southern coastal province of Fujian. He became a monk and was buried in nearby hills after he died of an old age. His tomb was later found to contain all the markings of Ming royal symbols. The records showed that Zheng He went to that temple twice and gave lavish royal gifts to the temple before and after his sea voyage from Fujian.
4
Reply
@indrajitgupta3280
4 days ago
Fascinating video. Thanks.
1
Reply
@lotus6560
6 days ago
Thank you for another interesting video
9
Reply
@colinbateman8233
3 days ago
I’d love to hear more on the exploration of the Chinese I think there’s possibly that they may have traveled to north or South America at some point we in the west commonly consider the history that we learn to be complete and factual when the reality is, is that you look at the Polynesians and the distance that they’ve traveled there isn’t any reason to believe that they couldn’t have also been to South America or parts of North America. It would be interesting to know other cultures, history, and how it compares toEuropean western version of history which as a Canadian living in the United States my view is that we have a tainted view of history in the sense that we only have a one-sided conversation if that makes sense I look forward to learning more.
1
Reply
@SteveYap-bp3im
4 days ago
Chinese Ming dynasty navy also visit Darwin (Australia) and present Florida in America. World's No 1 navy at the time.
2
Reply
@thomaskathy1
5 days ago
A very interesting historical aspect of Zheng He (correct pronounciation: is Zh… Her) exploration
10
Reply
1 reply
@GeorgeTSiy
5 days ago (edited)
The official and the unofficial explanations are not contrary .
The long period of not interpreting the tablets language is sheer incompetence or negligence of the people involved, not bec they couldn't figure it out ... With dragon symbol, size of tablet, obvious guess shd hav been Chinese. Ming period already used same scripts. The British were avid historians and normally would dig into such things , so the tablet was just never studied or brought to attention of scholars. Means also that the population of the area never bothered to remember the event the stone was made centuries earlier for commemoration and learning, opening access. Doubtless correlation can be made to speed ofnprogress of a civilization. The Chinese culture of putting records in stone on such events served it's purpose if surviving not only time but ravages of lack of curiosity or misuse like tuening to stone floors. Many such case in many parts of the world, like in Philippines.. where historical writings in stone are turned to floor tiles
12
Reply
1 reply
@philoso377
5 days ago
I have one question. With a fleet this large do they have communication and organizational problem from ship to ship?
9
Reply
4 replies
@Steven-k8t
5 days ago
PLease post the full translation of that tablet inscription. Thx in advance!
7
Reply
1 reply
@benkenobi292
5 days ago
Why is he sometimes referred to as Zheng He and sometimes as Cheng Ho?
5
Reply
5 replies
@gwang3103
5 days ago
It's good that Zheng He never colonized any of the countries he went to. Unlike later Europeans.
By the way, the correct pronunciation for the 'He' in Zheng He is her, not hee.
7
Reply
1 reply
@richardyatesyates3893
5 days ago
Best He info.❤๐
Reply
@EddieTsui
5 days ago
Pronounce the “He” in “Zhen He” as “her” not “He”.
7
Reply
4 replies
@chintham2861
5 days ago
Later on it was mentioned that the tablet was installed in a prominant place. The Sri Lankans obviously took the table like the Americans who brought down Saddam Hussein's statue, threw it into the water showing disgust. Of course, over centuries, the modern Sri Lankans lost the memory of Zheng He but still use Chinese fishing nets on the shore.
4
Reply
@bjung8858
2 days ago
Zheng He sailed West to find the last survivor of the last dynasty. Chinese cared less about trade. Personally, I think Zheng wanted to find a way to Mecca because he was a Muslim
1
Reply
@chew5461-l7f
5 days ago
Trust the British to be so ignorant to use the tablet as a floor tile!!!!!! I suspect it was spiteful and deliberate!
7
Reply
3 replies
@legpol
4 days ago (edited)
China & World History, the stone tablet was not brought to Sri Lanka 600 years ago by Zheng He because no original owner showed up to claim it. It was a plant planted by modern men of the 1911 years. If the Zheng He voyages were history, paper would do a far better job as evidence than stone. Unfortunately the Zheng He voyages was a novel, not a history and therefore no paper evidence was found.
You see? Whenever Zheng He arrived at the sea shore, he must write a letter on paper to inform the local governments of his arrival; and the governments must reply on paper. Was there such correspondence exchange? If none, it logically proved that Zheng He never went there. It was all a novel.
1
Reply
@who-dn5cl
5 days ago
Ancient Chinese had the spirit of discovery ( not exploitative nor colonialist intentions unlike the West ). Return of the Chinese civilisation in modern times promises great Maritime trade. to come.
17
Reply
6 replies
@pdmv8471
3 days ago
I think they knew full well where Jianwen went to. He renounced the world and became a Buddhist monk. Of greater concern to the Ming would be the families of the previous "Chinese" Dynasty...the Song. Ah, the Ming. The banana and orange cult....aka the sun and moon cult. Interesting Tibetan iconography. Dong Fang bu bai, anyone.
Reply
@emeritusprof.datolim4741
5 days ago
His name should be pronounced as Cheng Her
1
Reply
@legpol
4 days ago
็ณ็ขๅบ็พๆ，ๅปๆฒๆๅไพ็ไธปไบบ่ช้ 。้ๅฐฑ่ช็ถ่็ถ็่ญๆ，็ณ็ขไธๆฏ้ญๅๅธถๅป็，่ๆฏ1911ๅนดๆ็ไบบๆ ฝ็้ซ。้คไบ็ณ็ข，้ญๅ้ๅฟ
้ ๅฏซไบๅพๅคไฟก，็ฝ็ดไธๅฏซ้ปๅญ，็ตฆๅๅ。ๅๅๅๅไฟก。ไธไพไธๅพ，ไบคๆๆ่ฆ。็ถ่，ไปๅคฉๅปๆฒ็ผ็พไปปไฝไฟก็ด。ไธญๅไนๆฒ，ๅคๅไนๆฒ。ๆ
，็ณ็ขๆฏๅ็，็ดๅผตๆฏ็ฉบ็。ๆ่ฌ็้ญๅไธ่ฅฟๆด，็ถ็ถๅ
จๆฏๅ็。
Reply
@sinamark-com
4 days ago
Admiral Zheng He is pronounced Jeng Hรบh - not Heee
Reply
@yogikarl
5 days ago
Please pronounce his name correctly
3
Reply
@thomasridenour277
3 days ago
read the book , 1421 for more insight
Reply
@gideonchoong2534
5 days ago
Part of Zheng He fleet went round the Cape of Good Hope and reach Europe This fleet led by Zheng He 's 2nd in command settle in Europe and help spread naval technology to the Europeans who later colonized the rest of the world Zheng He has no balls to sail round the Cape of Good Hope because of the treacherous sea
1
Reply
1 reply
@godivachoco6509
4 days ago
I liked your video but you must learn to pronounce Chinese names and places correctly. I suggest you consult Chinese teachers about speaking Chinese names properly before you make a video. You must know that there are English speaking Chinese people who watch your video too.
Reply
@carrotsak
5 days ago
His voyage was to spread islam
COMMENTS: US abandoned the Philippines again: 07-01-2025
The US abandoned the Philippines again
Difference Frames the World
85.5K subscribers
Subscribed
2.2K
Share
Download
41,160 views Jan 7, 2025
USS Carl Vinson left the South China Sea unexpectedly after the Chinese destroyer patrolled the Huangyan Island.
Donate to support this channe
@ Patron : https://bit.ly/DFTW-Patron
@ PayPal : https://bit.ly/DFTW-PayPal
How this content was made
Altered or synthetic content
Sound or visuals were significantly edited or digitally generated. Learn more
Chapters
View all
Transcript
Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
Difference Frames the World
85.5K subscribers
Videos
About
Become Our Patreon
11:49
Jimmy Carter died in the US, but he is still alive in China
by Difference Frames the World
12:18
Boeing, Are You Still America's Pride?
by Difference Frames the World
12:13
China's Sichuan Opens a new era of amphibian ships
by Difference Frames the World
12:54
Here is why the US is afraid of China's 6th generation fighters
by Difference Frames the World
546 Comments
Eng Lam Yeo
Add a comment...
@MicheleLLOYD-bk2mt
7 days ago
Free Hawaii. And Guam. And the others……..
251
Reply
11 replies
@TheTraveler2222
7 days ago
Mao was not joking when he said "political power comes out the barrel of a gun", us Chinese will never forget that!
159
Reply
5 replies
@Niseedyyube6486
7 days ago
We should all free from western colonialism
148
Reply
4 replies
@oxvendivil442
7 days ago
I always argue about this with my fellow Filipinos but they just think I'm a traitor, China's needs to beat some sense not only to our government but also our people, we are too drunk on American cool aide, to the point we are little brown Americans and this is humiliating!
101
Reply
13 replies
@donatwu3128
7 days ago
It appears that the China's military is confident of its strength to deal with any potential reckless aggression by foreign powers in the areas. Every time when there is a provocation by the latter, the PLA will use the opportunity to train its soldiers & test its combat systems, not to mention that it will gather electronic data emitted from the intruders' systems which are in close contact with the PLA ships & planes. This may be a major reason why the US aircraft carrier retreats as soon as the PLA closes in.
100
Reply
@honfmeilingfleet957
7 days ago
not sure how US will protect Philippines when US can't even protect Afganistan
208
Reply
13 replies
@MASMIWA
7 days ago
By its actions, the Phiilippines has become a colony of the US (again) and a military target should a US vs China conflict break out. The US now has 9 military bases in the Philippines.
103
Reply
6 replies
@royalscot4116
7 days ago
If the Chinese armed forces were lurking provocatively in the waters surrounding Hawaii, of course the Americans would have something to defend in the interest of their own national security. If the US armed forces are lurking in the waters surrounding Huangyan Island then, of course the Chinese have something to defend in the interest of their own national security. The odds are heavily in favour of the Chinese if this game kick's off!
27
Reply
@misterbig9025
7 days ago
I am sorry for Mr Marcos. He is wearing leash with US flag
141
Reply
3 replies
@vanhocwong6689
7 days ago (edited)
It could be the 6th Gen fighters, introduced on 26th Dec 2024? In any case, good to see peace. And Marcos jnr wouldn't do a thing without permission from his master (who froze billions of his father's stolen money). News just out....Indonesia has officially join as a Full BRICS member (not a partner anymore).
71
Reply
2 replies
@mhoadievdelapaz3703
4 days ago
But Philippine mainstream media always hypes American warships๐
4
Reply
@mengreat6982
7 days ago
This old US warships or carriers shouldn't run here and there, " breakdowns is very expensive.... "
73
Reply
1 reply
@donkeykong516
7 days ago
US knows it can’t repair or build ships at speed, cost and scale of China, so US doesn’t want to play ship ramming game
102
Reply
@hkfoo3333
7 days ago
Actually US F15 growler EW tried to jam the Chinese ships but the Chinese ships beat the US EW and continued to lock on the US ships . So when their verticaal launchers were opened ready to fire at the US ships, the US broke off and ran.
After that the commander of the US carrier group got dismissed...
41
Reply
4 replies
@iWantPeace838
7 days ago
What do you call a bully who retreats? Coward!
89
Reply
@georgelim5006
7 days ago
Thank you for sharing this information. The Phillipines is sandwiched between two superpowers that’s a very fatal situation. Sorry to say it is only lose and no win for the Phillipines.
47
Reply
2 replies
@sjv9147s
7 days ago
The Hypersonics are not to be underestimated and the US Navy is well aware of the fact.
8
Reply
@BoiChongLee
7 days ago (edited)
Freedom of navigation in SCS is a myth as there are more Chinese merchant ships playing SCS simply because China is the world's factory and trades more with ASEAN & South Asian countries. There is more reason for Chinese warships & bases in the
SCS to enforce freedom of navigation there.
Therefore US intention is clear: To maintain it's domination over the
SCS as it thinks it can exercise it's hegemony over the world. But sorry, it is too late if one were to follow Prof Meisheimmer latest thinking. Now USA has to contend with Russia & China as rising superpowers.
A good advice to USA would be to do very well in enforcing freedom of navigation in the Red Sea. But even then, USA can't rope in Houthis!
24
Reply
@genghissu1185
7 days ago
Sai Pan and Guam need to be liberated from the US.
18
Reply
@AnnieT369
7 days ago
Did Bong bong get back the money stolen from the Philippino people?
38
Reply
3 replies
@eddiewong9272
7 days ago
Chinese ๐จ๐ณ PLAN 055 destroyer has with 112 vertical launch system (VLS) cells are able to launch YJ21, YJ18 and defence HQ19 missiles.
32
Reply
1 reply
@zulkanainbaharuddin2185
7 days ago
The Carl Vincent became Carl Lewis. Run buddy run.
50
Reply
4 replies
@ralphgoh2580
7 days ago
China is very keen and eager to test her store of new weapons..
15
Reply
@keikurooka5105
7 days ago
When was china joking. Wake up pinoys
32
Reply
@lachen7
7 days ago (edited)
PLAN should provide some videos of all such encounters. The US, British, Australian or Canadian navy/airforce, conveniently happens to have journalists on board, filming "unsafe and unprofessional" Chinese aircraft or ships flying/sailing near Chinese shores. The US and her vassals happens to come 12,000 km away from their shores near China to shoot such pictures/videos ๐
16
Reply
@lchsin59
7 days ago
As reported.... "American Aircraft Carriers cannot even solved it Toilet Bowl on board..... and .... "Protect The Philippines", what shit!"
35
Reply
@donaldmacdougall4679
7 days ago (edited)
China should remind the Yankee what happened the last time they caused trouble in the CHINA SEAS. Where they were humiliated to China Little Brother (Vietnam).
14
Reply
2 replies
@itelephone8796
7 days ago
We should have a picture of the US Navy torn and decrepit. incapacitated by battles with the Chinese!
10
Reply
2 replies
@erichuman
7 days ago
When did America win a war? Vietnam? Korea? Afagan?๐๐Doesn't have balls to pick equal. Always picking on Chihuahua. Only use proxy when meet with equal. Pathetic.
84
Reply
5 replies
@CK-mp9pq
4 days ago
The Philippines never learned the lessons. The US will abandon any country when it is obvious that their interest dwindled and the vassal country is no longer a value to its goal.
Reply
@UpsideDown-e2d
7 days ago
An entire US carrier battle group scared away by a single 055 destroyer? Unbelievable.๐ฎ
7
Reply
@Clarsair
4 days ago
Anybody can scare a U.S. carrier force away. The Houties do it about once a week. LOL
1
Reply
@zikaselovic785
7 days ago
Amerika svuda po svetu izaziva nestabilnost i ometa razvoj napretka na svim nivoima stvaranja. Treba je podrลพati u samoizolaciji::::::
24
Reply
@vicolew
7 days ago
i read somewhere, pls correct me i am wrong,,, a 4 x 055 destroyer can destroy an entire US battle group at sea with its immense surface to surface missles including mini hypersonic ones
16
Reply
@lingth
7 days ago
I am sure US Navy will say its not true, we are just going Malaysia for routine R&R .๐
25
Reply
5 replies
@nicb.1213
7 days ago
The US Military and Navy Blue Fleet meet PLA, they fled like scattered Rabbits. Do you think that the US with its Military Might capable and reliable to protect Philippines?!
14
Reply
@weemingngin5919
7 days ago
A Bully has no guts. A simple truth everyone knows.
12
Reply
@PutraMing
7 days ago
๐ฑ๐ฑ๐ฑ๐๐๐❤❤❤WOW GOD BLESS CHINA AND THE PLA
16
Reply
1 reply
@ooikk8458
7 days ago
The Houties are not afraid of the US navy and would the US expect China to be afraid of her ๐๐๐๐
27
Reply
@thepchaipoo6577
7 days ago
Hi Clara, it's nice to hear from you on DFTW.
5
Reply
@soonlooitan71
7 days ago
Uncle Sam are expert running away when war broke up like Afghanistan
12
Reply
2 replies
@AmuyedoSylvester-t9s
5 days ago
Trouble making is america's business.
1
Reply
@sssseow7121
7 days ago
A$2.99
Thanks
3
Reply
Difference Frames the World
·
1 reply
@michaelbarone7655
7 days ago
I think that all countries should just all stay in there backyard and mind there own buissness and not intimidate each other!
Otherwise there will be a big war on a massive scale. And it wont be the soldiers dying it will be the public to! Better to just have PEACE!
3
Reply
@ongchinlam4631
7 days ago
Interesting news. Okay
15
Reply
@keithtong9089
7 days ago
The only reason is this corridor is the throat of Asia out to the ocean
8
Reply
@ะะะฆะะะปะฐะด
7 days ago
❤❤❤ Might is right .. that has been the rule of the “rules based order “… China didn’t understand that in the 19th and 20th centuries and paid heavily for it. China has since learnt not to repeat that weakness… ๐
4
Reply
@raymondchan7839
7 days ago
You can try and you wil see what happen. ❤❤❤❤❤
8
Reply
@victorchew151
7 days ago
Should ASEAN countries use some leverage on this bong bong gov.
7
Reply
1 reply
@atatsmail260
7 days ago
Marcos Filippine behavior like pimp exploiting his customer
5
Reply
@ThePatricktan6
6 days ago
Duterte, bring him back...he is for the ppl
3
Reply
@timothyseeger5296
7 days ago
Never mind the 055 Destroyers , the 003 Carrier is carrying out Flight ops, and the 004 Super Carrier is being built , if you want to know more reference Eurasian Naval Insight , I've been following this channel for years , it's nice to see it back on YouTube after it was purged in 2022 , nice one people๐๐ฃ
2
Reply
@gideonchoong2534
7 days ago
How will the US if Russia or China put their aircraft carriers near Cuba and the Gulf of Mexico under the guise of freedom of navigation.??
Reply
@AlsonFlotildes
5 days ago
China's aggression in the West Philippine Sea is the source of tension in the region not the Philippines because Philippine troops never intruded into the EEZ of China.
Reply
@andrewpattison3716
7 days ago
No surprise Milley has destroyed the US forces
1
Reply
@haydonditchburn2194
7 days ago
The whole Military world knows very well that the presence of a US Battle Group is a toothless tiger when the opposition is able to fire back. With todays weapons, the flight deck of any carrier is a prime & inviting target. Disable the flight deck & you have taken away the carriers strike power. This is why the carriers have been the first to flee when faced with maritime hostilities. To remove the Pride of the USN would have a crippling effect on both the firepower remaining, as well as morale support of the nation as a whole. The US Carriers concept have been sold to the populations as the be-end-all of military firepower, when in reality they only hold that position when the enemy cannot fire back. A bit like the backyard bully really. They will always be the first to flee at the first sign of enemy action. And of course, the Philippine Navy would simply do as they're told by their US Puppet masters, The population of the US has no regard at all for the deaths or destruction of anything which is not American, (or Jewish) which is why the US has moved to Proxy forces to do their dirty work.
5
Reply
1 reply
@JerryAlquitela
6 days ago
PH should not depend too much on US under the new administration. I doubt US will trade PH to china to save its economy.
Reply
@youalo895
7 days ago
Philippines should be come USA state 51 for USA navy protect the Philippines country border line because we the US citizens middle income pay very high taxes, the million near and billion near are pay little taxes.
8
Reply
1 reply
@jacku8304
7 days ago
Background sound like the waves are more like noise than compliment the video. It should reduced the volume to a much lower level.
8
Reply
Difference Frames the World
·
1 reply
@wmchan44
7 days ago
This episode is a present day case of "็ๅ่ๅจ", the fable of the fox riding on the majesty of the tiger trying to frighten other animals.
Unfortunately for the fox when the "paper" tiger saw the dragon it quickly ran away leaving the fox to be eaten by the dragon.
1
Reply
@liho1738
5 days ago
https://youtu.be/wZ69hIxeHNg?si=fwhunyXPK4-Biye0
1
Reply
@dzungdang7465
5 days ago
god bless president Xi and CHINA
Reply
@glennchambers2802
6 days ago
Stay alert!
Reply
@thndrngest
7 days ago
In 2023, there was an hostile incident involved the 055 NanChang destroyer, where the encountered with the u s nimitz fleet. The alone mighty 055 heading straight on with all her YJ missile silos opened. The Nimitz class entire fleet made a big u-turn hastily. This formal report came to the public months later.
Reply
1 reply
@OrlandoQuiachon-g5v
6 days ago
Perhaps it is also relevant to consider if China's 10 dash line is acceptable to most nations or not. Trouble is that China is behaving in a manner expected of a GODLESS nation..
2
Reply
@liho1738
5 days ago
https://youtu.be/GLdAer3Dqr4?si=mfYr2m7g-Ey7P0eA
1
Reply
@chaz4609
7 days ago
Jai Hind. Europe and Middle East may not be freed from wars. But East Asia and even SEA including the Philippines should now be largely free from Wars for the next few decades.
Reply
@eddiecheang1513
6 days ago
China stay strong, protect your territorial integrity!!!
1
Reply
3 replies
@liho1738
5 days ago
https://youtu.be/n9dZnH1xXA4?si=OgVgoY6nmAocKpVm
1
Reply
@BenhurBaguio
6 days ago (edited)
Too many fools here who knows nothing about rules of engagement and china history revisions ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐
Reply
@JBear-in1ql
5 days ago
Is China being too assertive in its territorial waters and not following our rule base order again๐
Reply
@VirgilioBuyacao
7 days ago
Kingdom in this world will not last long no matter how rich you are. The arrogance of a country will collapse in a minute bec there is a God who sees all things, and only the Kingdom of Jesus Christ will reign gorever and ever
Reply
@VicGalamir
7 days ago
Wrong News your using Ai No prob china its a belong to the philippines
1
Reply
@worldlife9834
7 days ago
Explain the missile system provided by the US military. BS channel
4
Reply
@makuohua3071
5 days ago
U. S. Have lost its position in all faculties now it can't regains. As it depends on China in all ways. Even after wars needs China on rare earth minerals and construction financial help too as well as in Climates impacts. Even it needs China to survive am not joking wars means death. It can't win war China is not 18th century China now. DFTW you are not past DFTW now ๐❤love much of Analyst ๐thanks.
Reply
@sayeedsayeed8720
7 days ago
❤ CHINA ๐จ๐ณ ❤๐
1
Reply
@dzungdang7465
5 days ago
China power
Reply
@BoniTolentino-bp8gm
6 days ago
Do you think only one Chinese navy ship can prevent a carrier group of U.S NAVY SHIPS THINK WELL
Reply
@chatreal7396
6 days ago
Bong bong don't have half the wisdom of Duterte.
1
Reply
@toxified3937
7 days ago
trying to talk over waves seems, really unnecessary.
2
Reply
@ablefamilee6538
7 days ago
๐๐ผ๐๐ผ๐๐ผ๐๐ผ๐๐ผ
Reply
@limayanon
5 days ago
Propaganda of lies
Reply
@mycaespanola7684
7 days ago
mabuhay ang Pilipinas!
3
Reply
3 replies
@ericwright6672
5 days ago
Bullshit! That never happened
Reply
@esterledesma9849
6 days ago
Ridiculous propaganda
Reply
@DanielCadalin
6 days ago
This is CHinese propaganda.
1
Reply
@thethousandwordsvlog
4 days ago
For information china last island is Hainan, by Chinese astronomer.
Reply
@crazyqqq3
7 days ago
Of course run away. A destroyer is so much cheaper vs a carrier.
Anyone playing some computer games know this.
Reply
2 replies
@leoniegureghian7156
7 days ago
China ๐จ๐ณ made it Short & Sweet = Huzzah ๐๐ป ๐น๐ซถ๐ป
1
Reply
@PierisaulBanzon
7 days ago
Pro China commentary
Reply
@tenkuwatch9821
7 days ago
PROPAGANDA
Reply
@georgeloh8257
7 days ago
Wisdom men will say lives are more precious than a disputed shoal. The world is very big, so why sacrifices precious human lives for a tiny shoal? I believe everything can be resolved through the art of communication.
Reply
1 reply
@howtotext9820
6 days ago
Bull shit
Reply
@hahahuhu9828
6 days ago
Please make a video regarding taiwan USA internet cable cut.
Taiwan straight away accused China done it
Reply
@้ฆๆๅๅข
7 days ago
Free the silk road...free Africa...free pandas
1
Reply
@WilsonNolasco-s8f
6 days ago
Simulan nyo na kala nyo di abutin ang main land nyo ng mga kong range missiles?russia nga natapatan e allied e.
Reply
@Shanlung9
6 days ago
WANG SUI WANG WANG SUI ่ฌๆญฒ , ่ฌ่ฌๆญฒ ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐คฃ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ซถ๐ซถ๐ซถ. ๐ช๐ช๐ช๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ๐จ๐ณ WANG SUI WANG WANG SUI . ่ฌๆญฒ , ่ฌ่ฌๆญฒ
1
Reply
@limayanon
5 days ago
Hearsay
Reply
@garykuech50
5 days ago
china propaganda video
Reply
@zhugeliang3905
7 days ago
When did this happen?
Reply
@freeworld88888
7 days ago
Most powerful destroyers in the world
3
Reply
1 reply
@JorenzTanada
6 days ago
๐๐๐
Reply
@rmalunan1
3 days ago
Propaganda. Stop your lies.
Reply
@junecheong3370
7 days ago
Hv a beautiful prosperous new year 2025!
Reply
@aikteongyeap3774
7 days ago
Don't test t red line.
Reply
@jamierose4088
7 days ago (edited)
Oh right, some ancient chinaman put the island on a map, so is must belong to China. Right. Chinese logic.
Now see if you can stop the American fleet from sailing through the Taiwan Straight. Or stop Taiwan from calling itself independent Taiwan.
1
Reply
1 reply
@jatroTab0525
6 days ago
where is the yuan map that mentioning this crazy blogger? you must review your ancient maps from yuan to the last dynasty. this documentary is all a lie and misleading the trurh.
Reply
@limayanon
5 days ago
Fake account innvented story
Reply
@amdeguzman1
6 days ago
Fake mews
Reply
@vikingsreach
7 days ago
America has an endless amount of money for their Military, don't be fooled.
Reply
1 reply
@aungaisum8654
7 days ago
Why America is so chicken out against China ๐
๐
๐
.
1
Reply
@sengchuanng2004
7 days ago
Polynesian
Or
The Alasan.s
Reply
@jatroTab0525
6 days ago
guo jing did not reach the scarborough shoal,if guo jing made the stronomic observatory in scarbourough then where is it now? why there is no found even a single stone used from that observatory? keep dreaming...hahahhaha..
Reply
@phongy45
7 days ago
And why could the USA have so many land everywhere?
Reply
@Iris-ls6tu
7 days ago
Hahaha us film hollywood cinรฉma good
Reply
@EliodoroAlojado
5 days ago
Since then we are not affraid who wanted to destroy philippines will take the risk and they will learn a lessons.
Reply
@colinlee9678
7 days ago
Why doesn't Chinese Navy recover once and for all these 50 Spratly islands illegally occupied and militarized by the Vietnamese ?
Reply
@rubenmaprangala
5 days ago
Long Live the Philippines.
Reply
@Sagbotgamot
7 days ago
Philippines is a fierce bulldog IF his master the US is behind her. But if the dragon confronts her US master, the bulldog becomes a harmless Chihuahua. ๐๐๐
Reply
@rizebrond2545
7 days ago
Fake news?
Reply
2 replies
@danielarrozal2730
7 days ago
๐ด
Reply
@twicefan4709
6 days ago
Lets put it this way, the americans abandoned its poodle president marcos. Any surprise, not at all.
Reply
@namoi45
7 days ago
The Carrier had to return to base, because the ship ran out of toilet paper.
Reply
@phongy45
7 days ago
Really ????? Macro has millions USD at states .... 52rd states ????
Reply
@bluestar2253
7 days ago
Blah blah blah face-green-smilingface-purple-crying
1
Reply
2 replies
@lchsin59
7 days ago
By the way..... How many of them are fully operational?
Hmmmmmmm.... wonder!
Reply
1 reply
@mikesa239
7 days ago
Istorya
Reply
@Freedom2x462
7 days ago
I think this AI fake news, voice is robot!
Reply
@eventfulnonsense
7 days ago
For the trolls celebrating here,
You do realise how WW2 broke out, don't you?
All moves by Imperial Japan was well read by the US.
The US just doesn't want to fire the first shot.
And you all know how WW2 ended. Right?
Reply
4 replies
@JonasVenz-bc4yj
7 days ago
You have been paying by China..stop talking... about China
Reply
@Jean-Marie-k1m
7 days ago
Fake news.
Reply
@stevieg.9946
7 days ago
Chinese state propaganda.
Reply
2 replies
@Pilipinoako763
7 days ago
fake news....
Reply
@nestorportuguez8964
7 days ago
JOKES ONLY HAHAHA.
Reply
@LWRC
7 days ago
How do we know anthing reported in this video is even true??!!!๐๐๐
4
Reply
2 replies
@luanly747
7 days ago
no one is buying your BS,
1
Reply
3 replies
@ArnelVillatura
7 days ago
Fake news! Bwahaha
Reply
1 reply
@Rayjack-m9o
7 days ago
Difference Frames the World, What the hell is that suppose to mean ? Some ancient Chinese proverb which no one else understands .
Reply
4 replies
@Hamster-o1e
7 days ago
What?๐๐๐ China propaganda machines
Reply
4 replies
@bingut2525
5 days ago
Makakaliwa. Ai
Reply
@oliverpacada7237
7 days ago
Story teller BIG lie
1
Reply
@DB-rg4127k
7 days ago
Fake news
Reply
@darna2679
7 days ago
You are layer
Reply
1 reply
@huubdams9786
7 days ago
Just watched 10 mins. of sunset in an Asian sea(?) ๐ซฃ But thanks for the info anyway
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)